Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

127 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
MD
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Is mintop solution 5 better than tugain 5 in curing hair loss ?

Hi, im 24 yr old male my hair r fallin since last 5 yrs..n i didn t care abt them dat much..now i hv jst buy tugain solution 5 to grow my hair back..can u plz tell me is mintop solution 5 better than tugain 5?
Tue, 10 Jul 2012
Report Abuse
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,   ,  
Drug/Medication ,  
Treatment/Therapy
Medical Procedures ,  
Medical Topics
Cosmetic & Plastic Surgeon 's  Response
Hi
Thanks for posting on health care magic
It is normal to lose between 50-100 hairs a day, this is part of the hair renewal process as a phase of hair cyle . However most people suffer from excessive hair loss at one time in their life. There are many reasons for this including medication, radiation, chemotherapy, exposure to chemicals, hormonal and nutritional factors, thyroid disease, generalized or local skin disease, and stress.

Many of these causes are temporary and a few are permanent. These are some of the more common reason for hair loss.
As a 24 year male the most common cause of your hair loss is androgenic alopecia or male pattern hair loss though to confirm this i need to see you in person .So kindly take a consultation from any Hair transplant surgeon/dermatologist / trichologist to find the cause of this hair loss.
Ill tell you in brief about androgenic alopecia so that it is of help to you.
Androgenetic alopecia is a genetically determined disorder which is an extremely common disorder that affects roughly 50% of men and perhaps as many women older than 40 years.It is progressive through the gradual conversion of terminal hairs into indeterminate hairs and finally to vellus hairs. Patients with androgenetic alopecia have a reduction in the terminal-to-vellus hair ratio, normally about 4:1. Following miniaturization of the follicles, fibrous tracts remain. Patients with this disorder usually have a typical patterned distribution of hair loss.
Only 2 drugs currently have US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)–approved indications for treatment of androgenetic alopecia: topical application of minoxidil and oral tab finasteride.
Minoxidil comes in various brand names like for eg mintop and tugain .So the efficacy doesnt vary with the brand but the way of application .With the dropper take 1 ml of liquid minoxidil of any brand and apply on your scalp skin of the affected area and not on the hair itself.The application needs to be twice daily .these medications do not regenerate new hair .they will only help you retain the existing hair so that your degree of alopecia doesn't increase further.But before taking these you should consult a doctor specializing in hair problems to confirm diagnosis .
Also you may add antidandruff shampoo if you face the dandruff problem.
You may use parachute advanced scalp care therapy twice a week and wash it off in morning with X gain shampoo( twice a week only )
Take plenty of fish , green leafy vegetables , fruits and loads of water .

All this will help you retain your existing hair .If you want to replace the lost hair then you can undergo a hair transplant depending upon the grade and occurance of alopecia
I hope i have answered to most of your queries
If you have any more doubts feel free to post again
God Bless
I find this answer helpful
Dermatologist Dr. Bharat Chawda's  Response
Hi!
welcome To HealthcareMagic forum,

Both contains same chemical solution i.e. 5% minoxidil and thus both are equally effective.One thing which you have to understand that it takes at-least 2 months to start seeing the response. And these medicines have to be continued approx 6-10 months for good effect.Also along with this there are other additional medicines which one can take like finestride ,biotin zinc etc.
I would advise you to meet a dermatologist for same rather than self medication as side effects of medicines if any can be discussed.

regards,
Dr.chawda
I find this answer helpful
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer. For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service [Sample answer]
Share on
 

Related questions you may be interested in

doctor1 MD

i have been using hair 4 u solution for 1 month and i cant see any change in my hairloss...in fact it is the same as it used to be.........before that doctor has prescribed me mintop , tugain . i can see my scalp clearly after applyng lotion. a bunch of hair gets accumulated in my hands when i wash them . and the density is decreasing day by day. what should i do???

doctor1 MD

Hello Sir, I am a 27 yr old person, and I am suffering from hair loss from 6 months above. But from last 2-3 months my hair loss increases. Hair loss direct from root specially from front head. Recently i consult a doctor and he prescribed me to use following 1. Mintop / Tugain Cipla solution 5% ,to apply on scalp at night (i had purchased tugain as he says its effective more) 2. Nizral 2% shampoo to use alternate days for 15 days and than twice-3 a week. 3. Diprovate lotion : to mix its 2-4 drops in coconut oil and use on hair. 4. Zevit capsules I just wants to know that is : Is this medicines and lotion are FDA approved ? Is this is really effective ? Is any one of this have any side effects ? Is good effects of it persist even when i stop taking this medicine and lotion after 6 months

doctor1 MD

i am facing hairfall from 5-6yrs now.. i am 25yrs age... i have visited 3 docotrs now.. first gave me few tablets and mintop solution. i used for 3months and there was effect of it.. i was able to gain the hair.. but when i left the medicaton again it went.. Then i visited Dr Ashfaq sayyed Pune.. He have me Deut tablets and Mintop 5%.. and as he had lot of appointment i couldnt get appointment in the stipulated time.. Then i visited a ayurvedic doctor she gave me medicine for 3months again and it had bit effect and also did Shirodhara.. but not much effect.. Recently got medicine from Dr Anjali Bharve.. i m told to take medicine and apply Morr 3%.. will that be more useful than medicine i have taken earlier...and till what age i can try to gain hair..

Recent questions on  Alopecia

doctor1 MD

Hi,I am losing my hair n I am just 23. 1) When did you start noticing the problems - 1yr back 2) Do you have dandruff or any scalp conditions? They can increase hair loss, prompt treatment helps - itchy scalp but almost cured it. 3) Are you on any medications for any medical conditions? No 4) Are you married? No 5) How much hair do you lose per day? Do you see hair coming into your hand when you try to pluck a bunch? at around 150 6) How is your general health? Ok, Stress! Thanks!

doctor1 MD

I am facing hair loss for the past 24 months, lost some hair on the center and front of the head. I consulted a doctor and he suggested to use foltene pharma hair rejuvenator supplement with keraglo men tablet. I used it for 2 months and the result was very good. The hair loss stopped rapidly and also dandruff disappeared. It was good for 2-3 months and again the hair fall increased.

doctor1 MD

My daughter is 12 years old & has been a Vyvanse patient since she was 7. As a child, always having a full head of hair...she is suffering from severe hair loss. She started off on 20 mg. & now that she has moved up to 60 mg. the hair loss is even more uncontrollable. We were always told she had alopecia, We use steroid topical cream for her scalp, but locations of baldness are changing. Nothing seems to be working for her & we need help!!!

doctor1 MD

hello doctor,I have long hair , since 2009 every year in the month of june to August I face hair loss from roots.I am 26 years old, married and take a good diet and have no stress. More hair fall when I take a Head wash .also my scalp becomes itchy in these months. What do I do?

doctor1 MD

Hello Doc, I am having small to medium bald patches on vertex to front elevated side of scalp and few towards back. This is there since pas 5 months, for sometime they dissapear and now i had close cut and they reappeared back, when closely...

doctor1 MD

Sir I am suffering hair fall & severe head loss at middle of head. I consulted skin specialist who prescribed minoxidil solution 2% ;finaster idea 1 mg. But due to mild elevation in SGPT he told to apply minoxidil. I am trying for next baby; is...

doctor1 MD

Hello Doc, I am writing this to my previous interaction with you sometime before. I contacted you with regards to the problem to my hair, I had bald patches all over my head and later you have given me an answer. your last answer "I have reviewed...