Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

153 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Which is better among root canal treatment and filling ?

what is better rct or filling?
Thu, 25 Apr 2013
Report Abuse
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,  
Lab Tests
Dentist 's  Response
Hello and welcome to hcm,
As you asked ,there is no matter which treatment is better,it is the invovement of decay or infected pulp and periapical infection of tooth which decides the treatment of tooth.
If the decay is extended only till dentin of tooth,restoration is sufficient.
If the decay has progressed into pulp and periapical tissue,get root canal treatment done.
A thorough clinical and x-ray evaluation will help to rule out the Treatment plan.
Please get further check up by your dentist.
aLways maintain good oral hygiene.
Prevention is better than cure.
Get dental check-up in every 6 months.
Take care.
I find this answer helpful
Orthopaedic Surgeon, Joint Replacement Dr. Saurabh Gupta's  Response
Hello and Welcome to HCM,
Thanks for writing to us.
If there is pulp involvement then RCT is recommended otherwise restoration is sufficient.
first get an x-ray done to see the pulpal involvement.
visit the dentist and plan your treatment accordingly.
Hope this helps you.
Wishing you good health...
I find this answer helpful
Dentist Dr. Qazi Ammara's  Response

Thanks for asking the query,

RCT and filling are two different treatment modalities that totally depends upon the tooth condition.

Infection restricted to enamel and dentine with no pain, or just having cold sensitivity can be treated with filling.

Infection of the tooth involving the pulp tissue, hot sensitivity, tenderness over touching and grinding are treated with root canal treatment.

I would suggest you to take an x-ray of the tooth which will give the clear idea regarding the treatment.

Hope this helps out.

I find this answer helpful

1 Doctor agrees with this answer

Dentist Dr. Anshumala Singh's  Response
Dear friend.

thanks for sharing your concern.

filling is done when the decay is restricted only to enamel and dentin.

root canal is done when pulp tissue is affected,directly or indirectly.

therefore both are different modes of treatment and not an alternative.

hope i have answered your query.

take care.
I find this answer helpful
Dentist Dr. Benley George's  Response
There is no judgement between RCT and filling. A normal filling is done when dental caries is at the level of enamel or dentin. If there is pulpal involvement the filling done is RCT.
I find this answer helpful
Dentist, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Dr. Manish Gupta's  Response
Well you cant compare the two forms of treatment as both have their specific indications. Generally if a tooth can not be saved by simple filling then it has to be treated by RCT..... so it has to be decided by your dentist which treatment modality is best for you!
I find this answer helpful
Dentist Dr. E. Bharathikannan's  Response

filling and rct are different levels of treatment. cavity which cant be filled by filling will go for rct in which the damaged pulp tissue is totally removed and filled with artificial material. it cant be compared to decide which is best. take care!
I find this answer helpful
Dentist, Endodontics Dr. B. M. Rana's  Response
friend both the treatment modalities are best but which has to be carried out on your tooth thats totally depends on the tooth condition,i just tell you the symptoms so that you yourself can decide the treatment modality you should go for,if you have cold sensitivity to a particular tooth then only filling can be done and if you have sensitivity to hot then the only option is go for the rct,pay a visit to a dentist who can only judge corelating x-ray with clinical observation.
Thanks and wish you a good health
I find this answer helpful

1 Doctor agrees with this answer

Dentist Dr. Varun Mishra's  Response
welome to HCM,
rct is done when the infection surpasses the pulp of the tooth,, while filling is done when the infection is in enamel,dentin,, ie in the hard structure. if teeth pains on touching or on grinding ,then due to infection below teeth rct is advised most of times. hope you are cleared.
I find this answer helpful
Dentist, Endodontics Dr. Manisha Rao's  Response
HI, root canal treatment and filling are two different procedures which are carried out depending upon the extent of tooth decay. You dentist will decide the treatment plan after taking an X ray of the decayed tooth whether a filling will suffice (initial stages) or a RCT has to be carried out (deeper cavities). Take care!
I find this answer helpful
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer. For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service [Sample answer]
Share on

Related questions you may be interested in

doctor1 MD

I ve recently been having a root canal done, I ve been through 2 sitting and am 3 weeks away from my next , which will now be sooner because I ve seemed to have lose a large section of my tooth where the filling was, am I able to smoke and will it get infected easily?

doctor1 MD

Hi, I had a root canal therapy procedure done on one of my back molars yesterday afternoon after a tooth abscess was found and now have a temporary filling on the tooth while I wait until monday to get the rest of the root canal completed. Is it alright for me to smoke a cigarette? I know smoking is bad which is why I have cut back over time from about half a pack a day to now about 2 or 3, but I am really craving one- is their major risk with this?

doctor1 MD

I have a dentist (in my opinion screwed up a root canal on a wisdom tooth, which he filled first, put a cap on - then five days later decided to do a root canal. After the canal was done, my cheek swelled up and has remained grossly swollen for five days now). Instead of prescribing this when I first complained of painful swelling, he has now ordered two antibiotics, metronisazole 250 3 x a day AND azithromycin 250 for 5 days concurrently. Even my pharmacist thought this was VERY unusual...what do you think?

Recent questions on  Periapical cyst

doctor1 MD

hi!!! i just underwent an open surgery for chocolate cyst in my right per the clinical findings post operation...there were bi-lateral cyst of which the right one was only visible through PID examination has been removed and the left one been drained out...i would like to know whether i can conceive in the natural way or do i have to go for an IVF treatment????

doctor1 MD

I have Hard swelling in my gums and pain in the jaw. The swelling I hard and fixed but no bleeding in the gums and no toothache. I have pain in the lower me below the swelling

doctor1 MD

I had a MRI done on my right wrist and the findings was I have a small ganglion cyst measuring 4x7x5 mm near the radial styloid and a mild degenerative cyst formation in the lunate, the MRI was after I had surgery,what causes the cyst and could there be more forming?

doctor1 MD

I have a few very small cysts toward the bottom of my neck at the front. I've been suffering from some sinus problems as well as a sore throat so was wondering if they were related and that if the cysts were a reaction to a possible infection I may have?

doctor1 MD

can a bakers cyst cause another cyst in the lower outside of the same leg? I had my knee, calf, and ankle swell up on my right leg and was diagnosed with bakers cyst. the swelling is down, the pain is still there but not as bad. but now I have a small cyst on the outside lower right side of my calf.

doctor1 MD

For Dr. XXXXXXX Ward, dentist: I have a sudden gum swelling (mass) that appeared overnight. It is quite hard but doesn't hurt. What is it and what is the treatment for it I can expect when I visit my local dentist. Thanks, XXXX

doctor1 MD

Hi, I am a 25 year old female with no medical history. I don't smoke, drink, or do drugs. A couple of days ago I noticed a hard non-movable lump on the left side of my lower jaw (on the jaw line). It appears to be the size of a marble. About a...