Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

152 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
MD
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

National Guidelines that Medical Professionals are supposed to follow

Are there National Guidelines that Medical Professionals are supposed to follow ? An example is, a person goes to the Doctor with a strong Cough, Tightness in the Chest , and Shortness of Breath . During the Doctors exam the Doctor says he hears a rattle in the Chest which indicates fluid build-up. But he does not order Chest X-rays. Are there any guidelines that say Chest X-rays should have been taken? and before you tell me to get another opinion. it s too late. the patient passed away 2 days later of congestive Heart Failure ? The Doctor diagnosed him with Bronchitis .
Tue, 15 Dec 2009
Report Abuse
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,   ,   ,   ,   ,  
Lab Tests ,  
  User's Response
's  Response
There are no specific guidelines that any physician or medical provider is required to follow. Imagine the complexity of decision making in with all of the variations of various clinical presentations and medical histories. Depending on the setting, it is highly dependent on how a practioner might approach a presentation. In the ER I refer to it as "bottom-up" medicine. You assume the worst possible case, ruling things out as you go. You may or may not actually fully treat the presentation, but you have ruled out that the person is in mortal peril. In Family Practice however you often go with the MOST LIKELY case, expecting that if symptoms get worse the patient will return or go to the ER. We all want affordable healthcare. We ask our medical professionals to see 40-50 patients a day. We do not want unneccessary tests. Well all of that comes to a crashing halt the moment something goes wrong. Regardless of the work load, I do not know of a caring medical professional that would omit an important part of the diagnostic process because he/she was too busy, knowing that it might jeopardize his/her patient. Doctors cam make honest errors too. I am not endorsing necessarily what the practioner did or did not do, but I know there are plenty of cases of bronchitis that I have diagnosed without getting a chest xray. The example you provide does not exclude the idea that the patient had BOTH bronchitis and CHF. I can imagine several circumstances where patients can exhibit flash pulmonary edema and decompensate substantially in a few hours time - let alone two days. If this is someone you know or a family member, I am sorry for your loss. It is natural to look for someone to blame when things go badly. Unfortunately sometimes things look much more obvious in retrospect. If you feel like this practioner is really uncaring or is unconcerned or frankly is incompetent, then it would be wise to find another provider. If you think he/she is a good provider that made a mistake, I probably would stick with them. Good luck.
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer. For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service [Sample answer]
Share on
 

Related questions you may be interested in

doctor1 MD

I got my BP checked during a medical check-up, where-in reading was 150/100 after following test: urine test blood test ecg x-ray and after travelling 20 kms on public transport at arond 12 noon can i consider this reading as correct!!!! anyone pls advice.

doctor1 MD

doc, my first sgpt reading is 135. so the doctor told me to have a medication for 1 week and advice me to take godex 2x a day for seven weeks. after 1 week, i go back again and see wat happens. i was so disappointed with the result because i took medicines for 1 week and then my sgpt result becomes higher. it reaches 160 instead it decreases..wat should i do?please give me guidelines for wat i have to do to make it normal.

doctor1 MD

I am in the middle of an asthma/upper respiratory infection and was prescribed Methyliprednisolone 4mg. It is a 6 day run sarting with 6 today, 5 tomorrow, 4 the following day etc. I expected more information when it was filled and now I don t know if they expect me to take 6 of these pills tonight or 1 at a time...timed to get 6 in within 24 hours. I am leaning toward the latter. Please advise

Recent questions on  Dyspnea

doctor1 MD

Hi! I seem to cough every time I laugh. Been happening for almost 10 years. I went for a swim about 40m and I was wheezing, had shortness of breath, headache and felt faint. I also get a cough attack now and then which lasts for about 30mins and is mucusy. I have never smoked. Could I have asthma?

doctor1 MD

Every time I take a bath, I experience shortness of breath. It is painful and cough inducing to breathe deeply. I had asthma as a child and several case of pneumonia. Do you think this is caused by the moisture in the air somehow inhibiting O2/CO2 transfer in my alveoli?

doctor1 MD

My friend has told me ( he is 82) that when he lies down on his right side his chest hurts. I noticed his shortness of breath two nights ago when we had to walk about 200 yards to a ball park. He is complaining of indigestion- 2 days now. He has had a stent for 10 years, otherwise is in good health. Last night he did not sleep well. He does not feel it is a heart problem as he saw his cardiologist 3 months ago and was dealing with just some high BP-= 130/90

doctor1 MD

Hi there. I am a 35 year old female 5'7 155 lbs with a 7 month old baby delivered by cesarean. I have had shortness of breath that worsens with physical exertion since the last month of my pregnancy but am otherwise in good health. The last 2 months it has been getting progressively worse to the point where I have to catch my breath sometimes in conversation. I am taking domperidone to increase my breastmilk production and have been for 2 months. I have been to the ER where I have had an ECG, ct scan, x-ray and bloodwork, as well as a pulmonary function test. All results were within normal ranges except my oxygen levels in my blood were low - however the test was taken peripherally, not through a central line. Also, my resting heart rate was 118, and when I did a stress test, within 2 minutes my heart rate was at 200. They are sending me for an echocardiogram next. Do you think this could be adult onset asthma or a reaction to domperidone or is it my heart?

doctor1 MD

My pulmonologist said tests he did indicated need for echo stress test to rule out ischemic heart disease and referred me to a cardiology practice who scheduled the test. They even got approval from ins. co. I'm having symptoms and anxious (but...

doctor1 MD

I wanted to use our last conversation as a basis of my two questions but Ill have to just hope you remember what we talked of just a few weeks ago. I have Chronic Anxiety , I have GAD and have been in a chronic state for 4 years since my mother...

doctor1 MD

I have been having dyspnea , low energy for the past 6 months. My last ECG showed normal sinus rhythm low voltage QRS Borderline ECG. Should I see a cardiologist?