Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

193 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
MD
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Is it legal to place a magnet over a defibrillator to cause it to malfunction in order to cause death?

Is it legal to place a magnet over a defibrillator to cause it to malfunction in order to cause death??
This was done to my father and i am trying to find out if in fact it was legal. It was not that i know of, ordered by a physician. It did in fact cause my fathers death. This was done by my sister, she is an RN. She, along with another nurse working at the time are the ones that placed it over the defibrillator. It was not done to save him, and was done without the orders of a physician. I just want to know if I have any legal recourse as my father had a strong will to live and would have never agreed to this.
Sat, 24 Mar 2012
Report Abuse
Question is related to
Treatment/Therapy ,  
Medical Procedures
Lab Tests ,  
Cardiologist, Interventional 's  Response
hello n welcome ....
first of all use of magnet is commonly done by physician and during PROGRAMMING of pacemaker defibrillator. usually use of magnet done by physician in many occasions therapeutically.
if it happens by mistake or unknowingly even then death is unlikely. becoz magnet usually fix that pacemaker defibrillator in a fixed rate or programme.
i think whatever they have done may be therapeutically needed in that particular case.
that is the reason its usually says that person with defibrillator/pacemaker should avoid MRI /SCANNER in airport. that can cause malfunction but death is unlikely.
good luck ....
I find this answer helpful
  User's Response
Linda Smith's  Response
Uh, no... not only is it illegal but the Doctor should have known better. Rather accidental or purposely it is "Malpractice," in the medical field there is no room for mistakes because mistakes obviously cost lives. Was this Dr. Kevorkian???
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer. For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service [Sample answer]
Share on
 

Related questions you may be interested in

doctor1 MD

My doctor wants me to get a defibrillator because my ejection rate is at 25%. I am scared and do not want the surgery. My ejection rate has gone up over 3 months. I had chemo which caused the congestive heart failure. I would rather wait and see if my heart improves, but she is trying to pressure me.

doctor1 MD

HI. MY DAD IS SUFFERING FROM CHEST PAINS RADIATING OUTWARDS . IT HURTS MORE ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF HIS RIB CAGE. HE CURRENTLY WAS ADMITTED TO THE ER FOR CHEST PAINS AND WAS TOLD HE HAD A MILD HEART ATTACK. HE HAS HISTORY OF CARDIOMYOPATHY & DIABETES. 3 YRS AGO HE HAD A DEFIBRILLATOR IMPLANTED IN HIS CHEST. PLEASE ADVISE WHAT OTHER POSSIBILITIES THIS CAN BE.

doctor1 MD

i have just had a n operation to change my defibrillator to a more advanced new one.why? well i was on stage playing a concert in hard rock drumming and singing in the middle of the show defibrillator started heavly shocking me three times i got scared and went off stage.why did that happen now i am afraid to go on stage even the docs say you can do it.?????

Recent questions on  MRI

doctor1 MD

I had an mri completed and the found degerative changes in the lower spine with osteopyte formation and narroewing in some areas I also have a right shoulder pain and neck pain with a drooping eye which they found no explanation for. Does this mean i have osteoarthritis of the spine?

doctor1 MD

Hello, I am from Canada and suffer chronic pain and fibromyalgia for 25 years. I am on methadone as one treatment and it has been recently altered here. Methadose solution for pain 10mg/ml Methadone HCI 10 mg/ml. Dose, drink 1.5ml four times daily. I can not take this as I said it has been changed. Now the government has made it sugar based cherry flavored, gag reflux crap. I have tried to wean my self off but have experienced anger, smashing plates, cried out for doctor assisted suicide as the pain and withdrawal of this drug is making me crazy. I am on subcutaneous lidocaine infusions weekly, nerve blocks in neck and shoulders, cortisone injections in both hips for bursitis and nerve blocks in lower back, L4,L5. I suffer with herniated, degenerative discs, c5,c6 too. I have osteoporosis, parathesia, IBS, awaiting surgery for bladder prolapse, endometriosis which required hysterectomy and oophorectomy and numerous laporoscopies leaving me with adhesions which are a constant cause of further pain. I am a chronic pain disease sufferer and to the world I look great...haha! I initially started to write to you only for advise on taking myself off methadone but here I went on and on. The list is long and I see many doctors and pain specialists however my quality of life is nil and I am only 55 years young. I can not seem to find answers, help or hope other than being prescribed opiates, methadone which has been changed to suit the government not the patients needs and numerous medications that make me worse. I am on a roller coaster of hell and pain and now I am withdrawing off this horrible new recipe of methadone as I throw up trying to take it. Why change something that was easy to take to this horrible sugar based cherry cough medicine taste that burns to the pit of my stomach whereby I need gravol settle? I am frustrated, in pain and have talked to nurse on line tonight...she told me to go to the hospital...LOL! Right! I can not live in this pain...my doctor retired, great guy...now I have a woman who has nine kids and never can catch up or give a you know what about her patients. I give up! This is only the tip of the ice berg...you have now idea many health issues I have! I have to leave my city to go for help to Vancouver, thank God for HOPE AIR! They took me to the last appointment with my Neurosurgeon and he has ordered another MRI, will be seeing me after or before if I can not take the pain! I am a mess...What happened to good doctors??? How did we get FIBROMYALGIA??? I have a clue...DDT spraying all over the playground I grew up in...playground was a gas line and electric power field...what do you think of that? Five out of six women who played there as children were not able to conceive!!! Gee, I wonder! I am on a quest to find answers and thought perhaps I would start here...I doubt I will get an answer though...Great! Off to cyber space this goes...I am from Canada and You are in the States! Nice! I was on a Canadian site...how all of a sudden does it go here and now I need to pay! Well, thanks for nothing....I will proceed elsewhere because I will find an answer and from you...obviously not!

doctor1 MD

patient was admmitted with above complaints. all necessary investigations were done and managed conservatively.MRI brain showed acute infract in right corona radiata.chronic lacunar infarcts in pons,right thalmus,right lentiform nucleus and right corona radiata.USG abdomen showed solitary GB calculus.UGI endoscopy showed chronic active DU with duodenal stensosis pan gastriti with small pyloric ulcer.Grade B Erosive oesophagitis..bloodreports showed increased total bilirubin level.Gastroenterology consultation was taken for increasing total bilrubin ans was advised barium meal which was showed mild fold thickening stomach S/o gastritis.short segment stricture in post bulbar duodenum.patient was treated with LMWH,antihypertensives,antidiabetics,neurotropic agents and other supportive measures

my dad was advised to take the following medicines at the time of discharge can please help me by telling which medicine is advised by for what purpose

1. tab . Pan 40mg 1-0-0
2.tab . strocit 500mg 1-0-1
3. tab A to Z 1-0-0
4. tab LOSAR 25mg 1-0-0
5. tab clodrel 75mg 1-0-0
6.tab Ulcikit 000-000 * 5days
7.tab Amaryl 2mg 0-1(before lunch)-0
8.TAB strovas 10mg 0-0-1
9.syrp SUCRALFATE 10ML thrice daily 1 month.
please tell me detail why each medicine is used and when the dosage should be taken is it before meal or after..
IS Pan40mg and pantodoc 40mg are the same medcines..

doctor1 MD

My shin is burning from the inside,my skin is burning from inside out was all over me.From waist down.See over 50 dr s.Everyone is boggled.Allergists,derm,medicine,rhematology.etc...I have been on remicade,sulu cortef.I am on 3 vials ev/6wks.Recently been off a month.To see if it was that.Came back.Had a biopsy,mri,all cultures.It is hives that start on my bum always then spread down one leg then the other starts,turns purplish/bruised/goes away.My skin peels and I feel literally crazy,fevers,dizzy,itchy,forgetful my speech was off.Now I am limping with it mostly contained in my lower left leg now.It was as red as red.I have crohns.Also on depo provera and sulucortef.All I can do is ice it and take morphine and advil.Nothing is helping.Can t walk.Need some advice.

doctor1 MD

For past 12+ hours, I’ve had left side pain from left pectoral up through left shoulder and down my left arm to my hand. Sharpest pain is in shoulder, elbow and dorsal side of forearm. Some twitching in wrist and hand.

doctor1 MD

I had a discectomy and I woke up in excruciating pain. A week later a laminectomy to stop the pain. Epidural injection,Morhine, Dilaudid , nothing helps. Something does not seem right. My Dr. has released me and says it will take a year to get...

doctor1 MD

I have been diagnosed with spondylothesis of the L5 and S1 region. I have had an mri and x-rays for my back. I had an epidural injection(2) in Nov in my back which seemed to help the pain going down my legs for a couple of weeks. Unfortunately I...