Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

129 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Have arthritis in back and knee, torn medial meniscus and injured collateral ligament. Suggestion

Answered by
Dr. Saurabh Gupta

Orthopaedic Surgeon, Joint Replacement

Practicing since :2004

Answered : 5930 Questions

Posted on Thu, 31 Jan 2013 in Bones, Muscles and Joints
Question: Hi! I just found out today that I have torn medial meniscus, injury to my collateral
Ligament inner of the knee. With a spur. Also have spurs of the L4. I have arthritis
In both my back and knee. What do my future look like? I'm 39 years old
And work a physically demanding job. Which has been very painfully to do.
Thank you, XXXXXXX
Answered by Dr. Saurabh Gupta 3 hours later
Thanks for writing to us.

I can understand your problem. Before proceding further, Iwould like to know the duration of injury to collateral ligament and torn meniscal and also the grade of these tears if MRI was already done.

Let me know these, so that I can help you in better way.

Wating your reply...

Dr Saurabh Gupta.
Orthopaedic Surgeon.
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar
Follow up: Dr. Saurabh Gupta 2 hours later
The pain in my knee has been going on for a year and one month.
I thought it would get better on its own. Only got worse.
It's a grade 3. I didn't not go to the doctor until the other day then she
Sent me for the MRI. Thank you for your advise
Answered by Dr. Saurabh Gupta 13 hours later
Thanks for writing back.

Grade 3 medial collateral ligament tear may take 6 weeks or longer to heal and a knee brace or a knee immobilizer is usually needed for comfort.
Grade 3 meniscus tears usually require surgery.

As you have a physically demanding job, I would suggest getting this evaluated by an orthopedic surgeon.You may need arthroscopic surgery.

Hope this information helps you.I will be available for further guidance if you needed.
Please accept my answer in case you do not have further queries.

Wishing you good health...

Dr Saurabh Gupta.
Orthopaedic Surgeon.

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,  
Medical Procedures ,   ,  
Lab Tests ,  
Medical Topics ,   ,  

Recent questions on  Arthroscopic surgery

doctor1 MD

what are the treatment options (along with pros and cons of each) and healing times for discoid meniscus that is painful and causing clicking and grinding that occasionally feels like it's slipping?

doctor1 MD

I've had an eye problems since August 30th. ? I got it while at the dentist office August 22. He announced he was tired and just flew in from XXXXXXX and England. He wore no mask as he inserted final crown on upper right. When his receptionist...

doctor1 MD

I suffered injuries to my rt knee... MRI shows complete ACL tear, posterior horn of medial meniscus tear, and tibial plateau fracture ...How long do I have to wait to have surgery? Does the fracture have to be totally healed before surgery can be...

doctor1 MD

Good afternoon, I recently had an arthroscopic surgery done 2 days ago on my right knee and ever since I've been producing an unusual amount of saliva in my mouth. Is this a common side effect of surgery ? My throat is also sore as well as my lungs, but slightly.

doctor1 MD

I have received prolotherapy, prp (which did temporary relieve all pain in my knee, but has since returned), and two stem cell procedures using adipose tissue and spaced a year apart. All this was following arthroscopic surgery, physical therapy and cocks comb injections which provided no relief. The arthroscopic surgery made the knee even worse. After the second stem cell procedure, the pain tripled in severity and the physician instructed me to take three Motrin three times daily. After no relief in pain, he told me to increase the dosage to six Motrin three times daily, but again no relief. During the adipose tissue harvesting, he had an observer present who later left with some of my stem cells, but without my then knowledge or permission. In addition, I see that lidocaine from Hospira that was used might be part of a lot that was infiltrated during manufacture with metallic particles that could lodge in injection sites or be carried to other sites and cause severe pain, stroke, or other adverse effects. I have been complaining about increasing pain at all injection sites (knee, tibia, sole of foot), but have not had any success with resolving the issue. I did receive notice that Hospira manufactured the Lidocaine, there was no record of the lot number and that the facility did not receive a notice that they were part of a recall. I was a self pay patient and all is far worse following my August 2014 treatment than I was before treatment. The doctor said that he is sorry he couldn t help me and has me talking to a nurse who I have not heard from in two weeks. I recented made an appointment with an orthopedist at a nearby tertiary hospital who spent 8 minutes with me. He asked me to tell him what the problem was, never looked at my knee, took new xrays to the tune of $1100 and then stated that he would not operate on my knee. He told me that he was going to have me see another doctor who specialized in spinal surgery (I have a 22 degree curve that does not cause pain). The office staff was not alerted to this when I asked immediately after and told me that I would be called back. This was over two months ago and I am still waiting. I have a consultation with another doctor in June for evaluation for a TJR, but am now using a cane, walker and almost ready for a wheelchair. Before the last stem cell treatment and prp I still was walking without much pain so my hypothesis is that something in the lidocaine must have initiated the pain since every spot injected hurt and continued to and even resulted in a ruptured quadracepts tendon where injected when he tried to even up my posture. I will be calling Hospira to find out whether the bad lots of lidocaine were purchased by the facility that I had the procedure done at and take it from there. What is your perspective of my situation?

doctor1 MD

70 in September; athletic all my life; arthroscopic surgery right knee from torn meniscus march 2013; knee scan indicated cartiledge almost gone; significant knee pain after 100 yards walking; no problems sleeping; pain killers moderately helpful; is knee resurfacing a good prospect; should I expect good results? minimal or zero pain? active lifestyle without impact? expected recovery time? surgery technique? thoughts?

doctor1 MD

I am on disablilty through social development in BC, I have had numerous operations on my knees due to sports and physical injuries, 2 years ago I slipped, hurting my right knee which has had acl damage with hamstring replacement, I first say Dr O Farrell, who recommended arthroscopic surgery for cartilage removal, when I didn t hear from him or the Kelowna General surgical booking department, I called back to find he had retired, I was then given Dr. Curtis Myden as a surgeon, of the Kelowna Orthopedic Office, who I finally got to see today after sitting in his office for 2 1/2 hours, was told that the grinding noise was arthritis, fair enough, and that I walk poorly because of pain, absolutely brilliant deduction that is, and if I had money to pay for treatment or therapy he would refer for that, but since I don t, he guesses I should have another x-ray of my knee, which one would think he possibly could of thought of during the interim between referral and seeing him, I have asked my physician to refer me to another ortho, not in that office, as I don t believe we have a two tier medical system yet, where the wealthy get better treatment than the poor, it is also difficult for me as I live 80 kilometers away from Kelowna, due I have a valid complaint, which from what I read on the college of physicians and surgeons for Dr Myden providing inadequate care and/or treatment of my knee. I had difficulty getting the Ministry to provide funding for the transportation, and if I had missed this appointment, Dr. Myden would have billed me 100 dollars for missing it, to have absolutely nothing done about my knee except to be told that I walk poorly because of pain, and that if I could afford it, he would recommend therapy for the muscle wasting in my knee, and to get another x-ray, as the previous one is two years old. Do we have a two tiered system where doctors can bill people for missing appointments due to weather and transportation costs, and to not try to seek alternative arrangements for care, of a person, regardless of income level, or even in spite of it here in BC that I know nothing about?