Get your Health question answered in 3 easy steps
A Doctor will be with you shortly
Ask a Doctor Now
200 Doctors are Online

Depression tests suggest near to or sever depression. Answered questions wrong? Electing ECT wise?

User rating for this question
Very Good
Answered by

Practicing since : 1998
Answered : 415 Questions
I have taken many depression tests lately and most suggest that I am near to or on Sever Depression and need to seek Psychiatric help. I wonder whether I have answered the questions wrongly. It asks about suicide. I am 74 and if I lost my wife, being resourceful I have had to answer positively. Questions about crying, whenever I get reminded about history, mine or otherpeople I get very emotional and this happens often, so I have had to say I cry a lot. Whenever I think about what I may have done in history, yes I feel guilty and derserve to be punished. Have I misunderstood the questions or should I really seek help. If I have to seek help and they find that I am a depressive will I be able to elect my treatment. i.e. could I refuse drugs and elect for ECT. Supposing this happened and I signed my acceptence of ECT would that mean it must go ahead or can I change my mind. I feel that it could be feerful and I would prefer that I could not change my mind at the last minute so as to speak.
Posted Sat, 5 May 2012 in Mental Health
Answered by Dr. Susanta Padhy 16 hours later

Thanks for the query.

I will be able to identify your problem better if you can respond to the following:

1. When did you lose your wife?

2. How is your social support since then?

3. Do you have any past history of depression or anxiety in your life time?

4. Do you have any such (depression) family history?

5. Your current status of prostate and the further plans of its management?

6. What type of personality do you have?

7. Do you currently have sleep disturbance, loss of interest in previously pleasurable activities, low confidence, negativity about your thought process, memory problem, attention and concentration problems?

8. What tests did you undergo for depression?

I will be in a better position to answer whether are not you have depression / pseudodementia / dementia / complicated grief or if you are normal. All these are possibilities here.

And regarding depression, these days depression is very well treatable with medications. Majority, practically don’t need Electro Convulsive Therapy (ECT). If the depression is mild, it can be treated with "counselling" without medication. For moderate to severe depression, usually medications are very helpful.

Antidepressant medications however need to be chosen in the context of medical or surgical history of the individual.

Hope I answered your query.

Awaiting your reply.

Wish you good luck and thank you once again.

Above answer was peer-reviewed by
Follow-up: Depression tests suggest near to or sever depression. Answered questions wrong? Electing ECT wise? 2 hours later
\in answer to your queries{-
(1) She is still alive but I would be devastated to lose her.
(2) N/A
(3) No, but I sought psychiatric advise in my youth
(4) My granfather died of Melancola. (I think its spelt wrongly)
(5) All fine now excepting that I wear diapers 24/7
(7) I sleep for very long periods, I've lost interest in golf and my property in Spain.
I do have a memory problem and I find it very difficult to read and concentrate
(8) Various test on the internet
I hope you can now resolve my queries
Answered by Dr. Susanta Padhy 1 hour later
Thank you for the answers

I am really sorry for the misinterpretation

So, obviously complicated grief is not a possibility

Sleep disturbances (more or less ), decreased attention and concentration , loss of interest, fear, apprehension, anxiety, subtle memory problem (like day to day forgettfullness, forgetting trivial issues )all are symptoms of depression.

memory disturbances in the setting of depression is called as pseudodementia, means, actually no dementia is there, but symptoms mimic that of dementia)

Memory impairment can also occur in Dementia. But here lack of memory to even important and significant events, situations, wealth etc. Here patient does not report about his memory impairment but on memory tests he is not able perform.

whereas, in Pseudodementia, client will have normal or near-normal memory on testing, but he will complain of memory loss disproportionately.

Other features of dementia are language disturbances, impaired judgement, loss of motor skills, misrecognition etc with progressive worsening of memory. In your case it does not seem to be dementia, but because Your current age of 74, and you have heart problems one need to rule out dementia neurology / psychiatry consultation.

In addition, to inform you, not to confuse you, often depression can be an initial presentation of dementia.

If it is depression, treatment possibilities I have discussed in my previous answer.
Psychiatrists job is to inform you not to force you the tratment. Selecting the treatment option is entirely upto you and your family.

However, if it is dementia, then it need to be subtyped and treated accordingly, by a neurology consultation

Overall, it is wise to take neurology and psychiatric consultation, particularly keeping your age, heart problem, prostate problem, family history and past history of psychiatric ailments.

Hope, I answered your query

I am available for further discussion

Good luck
Above answer was peer-reviewed by
Follow-up: Depression tests suggest near to or sever depression. Answered questions wrong? Electing ECT wise? 1 hour later
Thank you for your response. I now realise that I have not told all. Both of my Grandfathers died as in patients in Mental Hospitals. When I sought advice they wanted me also to become an in patient at a Victorian Mental Institution. When they saw my fear they fortunately changed their minds. Further to the question regarding my wife, if anything did happen and I was left alone, I would not wish to continue life. I would seek some remedy. I don't know whether that modifies your views. Regards XXXXXXX Docker
Answered by Dr. Susanta Padhy 15 hours later
Hi and Thank you XXXXXXX Docker for your seeking further clarifications,

Opinion would remain more or less same, and at the same time I must thank you and proud of you for acknowledging that you need specialty consultation.

In fact you must seek Psychiatric consultation on priority basis and try to comply their advice after clearly discussing everything. Also no harm in taking Neurology consultation.

I am sure you will be benefited with the consultation.

Wish you all the happiness and good health.

Thank you

Above answer was peer-reviewed by
Follow-up: Depression tests suggest near to or sever depression. Answered questions wrong? Electing ECT wise? 5 hours later
Thank you for your reply. You have been very gentle with me. I was going to ask you how urgent it is for me to be face to face with a Psychiatrist but you have now answered that question. All the tests that I had taken showed severe depression. I thought that you were playing that down. I now realise and thank you for handling it this way. I feel that once I have been put in front of a Psychiatrist he will be very exacting. I can handle that and I hope that I have read the seriousness of my situation. I must re ask the question of you knowing my ancestry and problems, Do you think I will have to spend some time in a Psychiatric ward during the rest of my life?. I need to prepare my mind. Thank you so much
Answered by Dr. Susanta Padhy 1 hour later

Thanks for writing back.

Answering your question directly, I dont think that you need hospitalization for rest of your life, but again it depends on final assessment of your psychiatrist. And I am sure their assessment would be evidence based.

To add, there are few conditions that need hospitalization for life long, moreover they are the options, after all available treatment options failed. In your case, think not to many treatment options have been tried, as of today.

Thank you very much and wish you a speedy recovery
Above answer was peer-reviewed by
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Google+
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions

The user accepted the expert's answer

Ask a Psychiatrist

© Ebix, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
All the information, content and live chat provided on the site is intended to be for informational purposes only, and not a substitute for professional or medical advice. You should always speak with your doctor before you follow anything that you read on this website. Any health question asked on this site will be visible to the people who browse this site. Hence, the user assumes the responsibility not to divulge any personally identifiable information in the question. Use of this site is subject to our Terms & Conditions
Already Rated.
Your rating:

Ask a Doctor