Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

146 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Do calcium supplements cause asthma?

Answered by
Dr. Ivo Ditah

Internal Medicine Specialist

Practicing since :2002

Answered : 3919 Questions

Posted on Thu, 9 Mar 2017 in Medicines and Side Effects
Question: i have been advised by my doctor to take OTC calcium 600 mg plus vitamin D3 800 iu which i need for bone density improvement. I have a history of severe asthma and it had subsided considerably over the last couple of years however it flared back up to the historical status when I started taking the calcium plus vitamin D. I took it for 10 days. The asthma problem flared up the 1st night and continued day and night that 10 days. I discontinued taking it after 10 days and my asthma problem went back to its semi-inactive status. Your web site lists approximately 150 meds for osteoporosis. Can you advise me which ones do not trigger breathing problems so i can make a selection, in cooperation with my family doctor, that will correct my bone density problem without causing me an asthma problem. Thank you !!!!
Answered by Dr. Ivo Ditah 1 hour later
Brief Answer:
Change the generic type!

Detailed Answer:

The ingredients and probably not calcium are responsible for these symptoms of recurrent asthma. I will suggest that you change the brand and get another genetic form. If the same symptoms occur again,. I will then advocate that we should change. Other medications for osteoporosis are used when bone loss is advanced as the side effects are some what a limiting factor to use just like we use calcium for primary prevention.

Try this out and let me know what the results are. We will continue, from there.

I hope to hear from you on this. I wish you well and feel free to follow up with me if need be.

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,   ,  
Lab Tests
Medical Topics

Recent questions on  Severe asthma

doctor1 MD

I am a 67 yrs old male(widower), had a heart attack in 1994 and bypass in 2007, been having high BP for the last 20 yrs. and taking medications to control it under supervision of a cardiologist. Had a severe asthma attack after a bout of bronchitis which i ignored. I have been taking half tablet of montair lc along with 2 tabs each of telmisartan 4omg and amlodipine 2.5mg daily along with the above and restyl 0.5mg at night since I have insomnia. Frankly all these medicines make me tired and irritated and i dont feel motivated to do anythig. Is there anything you can suggest. Thanks.

doctor1 MD

We have a 17 year old son who is on Xolair Injections every 2 weeks for his severe Asthma. Also, daily maintenance meds of Symbicort, Allegra D and Zyflo. Has been on Xolair for close to 9 months. His symptoms appear no better - His doctor has been literally "scratching his head" as to why his treatments are not working - even ordered echocardiogram which came back normal. Here is probably the problem..... Right after that about 2 weeks ago, we found that he has been chewing tobacco the whole time. Would this cause adverse reactions to cause the medicines not to work. We are doing everything we can to get him off of it, but he defies his father by saying he will not quit. We are grasping at anything that will "scare" him to know how bad this is. Please help us if you can. There is no way that the nicotine cannot be harmful to his lungs which are already weak -- and I don't have to tell you how much we are spending on the Xolair to keep his lungs "healthy" - and looks like it is being wasted.

Thank you in advance for your reply. e-mail: YYYY@YYYY

doctor1 MD

I have asthma , I am using inhaler near about 10 times a day now a days. Can you suggest any long term solution or Cure of it.

doctor1 MD

My father (age 61) has been rushed to the hospital twice within the past 6 months due to under going a severe asthma attack. They have checked his lungs, heart, and chest and continue to say that everything looks perfectly fine. Though this may be the case, it is unsettling not knowing exactly what can cause an attack and then his inhaler alone cannot fix this problem. Any advice or suggestions?

doctor1 MD

I have cramps in my fingers, toes, and legs, thigh. @ different intermittent times mostly @ night. what causes this? I have had mild episodes in the past and have been talking magnesium and potassium with good result but not so lately. In the ast...

doctor1 MD

I have been diagnosed with severe allergies and asthma. About 12 years ago I underwent desensitization which was very helpful for several years. However, my allergies are getting much worse again and I had to be hospitalized for several days...

doctor1 MD

My mom just broke her femur just below the trachanter (within the last 24 hours). She had surgery and had a titanium rod and pins placed. She is 58 years old, about 125lbs, and significant respiratory history - severe asthma, COPD, she has gone in the hospital 8 times for respiratory failure, 5 times needed to be intubated, and also has osteoperosis (caused by being on Prednisone for many years - rarely gets below a 10mg doasge or else goes into an asthma flare.) Each time she has gone into the hospital for her respiratory failure, she loses leg muscle and has to do physical therapy. She actually just finished 6 weeks of PT about 2 weeks ago. Because of her health problems, I know she will take a longer recovery time. What exercises can she possibly start now to reduce muscular atrophy? And is there anything that we can do to help speed up recovery?