HealthCareMagic is now Ask A Doctor - 24x7 | https://www.askadoctor24x7.com

question-icon

Is Fish Oil Or Krill Oil Good For Bone Health?

default
Posted on Mon, 12 May 2014
Question: Hello. I'd like to ask about fish and krill oil, and other high omega 3 oils like flax, hemp, walnut. I hear a bit about krill oil being more effective for cholesterol, but what about joints? And brain health? I have been diagnosed with osteoporosis, and wondering whether fish oil or krill is good for bone health. Does it contain vitamin D? I've been told that fish oil is rich in DHA while the vegetable oils provide AHA. Does that mean we need both? And does one need fish oil as well as krill? Is salmon oil the best form of fish oil? While we're on it, I'm told that some saturates are important, but could you tell me why? Is coconut the best form? What else? Lot of questions here. Hoping for some clarification. Regards XXXXXXX
doctor
Answered by Dr. Vaishalee Punj (6 hours later)
Brief Answer: DHA ARA has side effects Detailed Answer: Hi Thanks for posting your query on HealthcareMagic. I will try to answer your questions to the best of my knowledge. I hear a bit about krill oil being more effective for cholesterol, but what about joints? A. It has been boasted to have effects on cholesterol and joints. It does relieve the pain for some time. Mostly companies that manufacture these products use these claims for advertising their products and these claims are mostly not backed by research. And brain health? A. I personally do not think that it increases intelligence. It does make the person irritable, which may seem like enhanced brain activity to an observer. In fact the person has most brain health when he does not take any medicines. Kids brain is most active because they have not been exposed to much of medicines. I have been diagnosed with osteoporosis, and wondering whether fish oil or krill is good for bone health. Does it contain vitamin D? A. No it does not contain vitamin D. You will need calcium and vitamin D supplements for osteoporosis under medical supervision. I've been told that fish oil is rich in DHA while the vegetable oils provide AHA. Does that mean we need both? A. Fish oils contain both DHA and ARA. There is no doubt that we need both DHA and ARA. But the DHA and ARA that is needed for humans has different pharmacological composition then that present in fish and other sources. So it does not do the same job as human DHA and ARA. And does one need fish oil as well as krill? Is salmon oil the best form of fish oil? A. All forms available are similar with only little differences in side effects. If you really want to, you can take just any. I would recommend taking fish and nuts rather than their oils. Take it in moderation. While we're on it, I'm told that some saturates are important, but could you tell me why? Is coconut the best form? A. Yes some saturates are important. They are typically animal in origin, like milk, milk products, etc. They are important because they are needed to provide energy, serve carriers for vitamins, for the formation of cell membranes, etc. FDA recommends clearly that only 30% of calorie consumption should come from fats. From among fats, only 30% should be saturated fats. This much fat is usually present in the routine diet that we take. Moreover saturated fats are not essential fats (Essentials fats means that we need to take them to replenish them in our body). But the issue is that saturated fatty acids predispose to cardiovascular disease by increasing the LDL-C levels. So I would not recommend you to take them outside the routine diet. Take a well balanced diet. What else? DHA and ARA have side effects and predispose to gastrointestinal symptoms like diarhea, bleeding from gut. There are other side effects like irritability, rashes, etc. Hope it helps. Let me know if I can assist you further. Dr Vaishalee
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Prasad
doctor
default
Follow up: Dr. Vaishalee Punj (15 hours later)
Thank you very much Dr. I think I meant ALA, as referred to below. " The “3″ in Omega-3 refers to the major types of fatty acids that are ingested in foods and used by our body: alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Once eaten, the human body converts ALA to EPA and DHA which are more readily used by the body. Omega-3 is an important component of almost all cell membranes; therefore, sufficient amounts of these fatty acids are necessary and need to be balanced to maintain good health." Thanks for your clarification on fish and krill, and saturates. I hear you that its better to eat whole foods than take supplements. I have been vegan ,but try now to have some fish, as I had a fracture recently. I don't use dairy much but have soy. Do you think I can get the required saturates and calcium from soy? Thanks for your help. XXXXXXX
doctor
Answered by Dr. Vaishalee Punj (7 hours later)
Brief Answer: Soy has low saturates and calcium Detailed Answer: Hi again Soy can provide calcium if it is fortified with it. It is not a good source of saturates. Isoflavones in soy can help strengthen the bones. You must be knowing already that you need calcium and vitamin D supplements. To heal the fracture better, you can try SERMs (a group of medicines like raloxifene) under the supervision of a gynecologist. It helps strengthen bones by directly estrogen (a female hormone) towards bone healing. It is particularly useful in post-menopausal osteoporosis. Alternative therapies for the prevention and the treatment of osteoporosis in postmenopausal women include HRT or ERT (hormone or estrogen replacement therapy under gynecologist supervision), bisphosphonates, calcitonin and parathyroid hormone. Hope it helps. Dr Vaishalee
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar
doctor
default
Follow up: Dr. Vaishalee Punj (15 hours later)
Thanks Dr Vaishalee. Now I have some names of medications I can research. I hate taking medications and have been very sceptical of hormone replacement therapy, but I know estrogen levels drop in and after menapause. I will talk to my own Doctor soon. She phoned me to give me the results of bone density test three weeks ago and I haven't wanted to go there. But am glad I have consulted you. I really do have to take this condition seriously. XXXXXXX
doctor
Answered by Dr. Vaishalee Punj (7 hours later)
Brief Answer: My pleasure Detailed Answer: Hi again I am glad I was able to help you. You need to take it seriously. Thanks for consulting me Take care Dr Vaishalee
Note: For further follow up on related General & Family Physician Click here.

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar
doctor
Answered by
Dr.
Dr. Vaishalee Punj

General & Family Physician

Practicing since :2003

Answered : 3266 Questions

premium_optimized

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on

Get personalised answers from verified doctor in minutes across 80+ specialties

159 Doctors Online

By proceeding, I accept the Terms and Conditions

HCM Blog Instant Access to Doctors
HCM Blog Questions Answered
HCM Blog Satisfaction
Is Fish Oil Or Krill Oil Good For Bone Health?

Brief Answer: DHA ARA has side effects Detailed Answer: Hi Thanks for posting your query on HealthcareMagic. I will try to answer your questions to the best of my knowledge. I hear a bit about krill oil being more effective for cholesterol, but what about joints? A. It has been boasted to have effects on cholesterol and joints. It does relieve the pain for some time. Mostly companies that manufacture these products use these claims for advertising their products and these claims are mostly not backed by research. And brain health? A. I personally do not think that it increases intelligence. It does make the person irritable, which may seem like enhanced brain activity to an observer. In fact the person has most brain health when he does not take any medicines. Kids brain is most active because they have not been exposed to much of medicines. I have been diagnosed with osteoporosis, and wondering whether fish oil or krill is good for bone health. Does it contain vitamin D? A. No it does not contain vitamin D. You will need calcium and vitamin D supplements for osteoporosis under medical supervision. I've been told that fish oil is rich in DHA while the vegetable oils provide AHA. Does that mean we need both? A. Fish oils contain both DHA and ARA. There is no doubt that we need both DHA and ARA. But the DHA and ARA that is needed for humans has different pharmacological composition then that present in fish and other sources. So it does not do the same job as human DHA and ARA. And does one need fish oil as well as krill? Is salmon oil the best form of fish oil? A. All forms available are similar with only little differences in side effects. If you really want to, you can take just any. I would recommend taking fish and nuts rather than their oils. Take it in moderation. While we're on it, I'm told that some saturates are important, but could you tell me why? Is coconut the best form? A. Yes some saturates are important. They are typically animal in origin, like milk, milk products, etc. They are important because they are needed to provide energy, serve carriers for vitamins, for the formation of cell membranes, etc. FDA recommends clearly that only 30% of calorie consumption should come from fats. From among fats, only 30% should be saturated fats. This much fat is usually present in the routine diet that we take. Moreover saturated fats are not essential fats (Essentials fats means that we need to take them to replenish them in our body). But the issue is that saturated fatty acids predispose to cardiovascular disease by increasing the LDL-C levels. So I would not recommend you to take them outside the routine diet. Take a well balanced diet. What else? DHA and ARA have side effects and predispose to gastrointestinal symptoms like diarhea, bleeding from gut. There are other side effects like irritability, rashes, etc. Hope it helps. Let me know if I can assist you further. Dr Vaishalee