Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

174 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

My mother is 48 7 has thyroid & doctor suggested spinal decompression surgery. How effective is it ?

My mother is 48 yo, 5 4 , 87 kgs. She also has thyroid for which she is under Thyroxine. She is suffering from extreme lower back pain for the last 4-5 years which radiates to her limbs and she can t walk without stopping frequenly and pain increases on lying down. On MRI it was found that Harniation of disk at L4-L5. After traditional Yoga and physiotherapy without any improvement the doctor suggested Spinal Decompression Surgery. How effective is it ? What are the risks ? How much can be its approximate cost and where can this be done in India ? What if the surgery is not done , isn t there any non-intrusive way? Please help.
Mon, 13 Jun 2011
Report Abuse
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions
Medical Procedures
Lab Tests ,  
Medical Topics
  User's Response
's  Response
Patient's perspective: Your mother is obese and possibly has got a huge stomach. If your mother wants a non surgegical way, she must lose weight by 20kgs at least. If she is not diabetic now, she will be very soon.

It may not be necessary that the herniated disc at L4/5 which is due to overweight probably may not be the only cause of the pain.

It also appears that at that weight she is lazy or unable to do exercise. Buy her a crazy Fix vibratory machine. This exercise equipment will require her to only stand on it for 10 minutes and will help lose weight. Her stomach must go in first as it carries too much baggage. Also get her several sessions of full body massage which should last about 1 1/2 hour per treatment.

Reduce her portion of food if she likes her food too much. Drop down quantity, but tell her she can still eat again a light meal 3 hours later. This will still feed her same amount of food, but will start shrinking her stomach size. After a months she will find that she does not get hungry in between and will develop a habit of taking out less food.

Together with these 3 combination of treatment, she may find the back pain is completely gone! And if she goes under surgery, there is no guarantee that the bulge is the only thing that is giving the pain. She may end up getting worse.

General & Family Physician Dr. Ramesh M.Vachharajani's  Response
Thanks for query,
Your mother has to under go decompression surgery,there is no option.
Result are good,
There is no risk as such,
Cost of surgery varies from city to city,
In any big city this surgery is done.
If not treated she may develop hemi plegia and disability.
ok and bye.
I find this answer helpful
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer. For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service [Sample answer]
Share on

Related questions you may be interested in

doctor1 MD

Can you please tell me how scar tissues can be minimised or prevented after a spinal decompression surgery? Patient is advised to keep mobile as much as possible. Reading articles online about scar tissues highlight that scar tissues develop as part of the healing process and also from any swelling or inflamation. Small exercises can cause inflamation or swelling also and that pain can emerge from the scar tissues after 12 weeks. Can any steps be taken to minimise or prevent scar tissues during the recovery process? It is now 3 weeks after the surgery. Thanks. Regards, PN

doctor1 MD

I am a 70 year old type2 diabetic in need of decompression back surgery. While surgeons downplay potential s, others. Say the risks of heart attacks, strokes, blood clots, and the likes. Should I learn to live with pain and pain meds ... or has technology made such procedures less complicated? Thanks, Ohio I understand each case must be examined individual, yet at my age, an extended recovery of unknown duration must offer a decent percentage of ambulances recovery

doctor1 MD

I just recently learned that I have a large lesion on my thyroid gland which will be biopsied next week. I had a spinal decompression treatment and it appears to have relieve the pain that I was experiencing in the thyroid glad area of my neck, is this possible?

Recent questions on  Thyroid

doctor1 MD

Hi i am 31 years old and from severe hairfall from more then 3 years, i have thyroid for that i am taking 62.5mcg thynorom tablet, so it is under control. I have consulted dr, she prescribed me minoxidil 2%, because of that my hair become so hard and dry so she changed it to grocapix gel and tricotan forte tablet, i am following this treatment from more than 2 months but still no effect, even no now my forehead is becoming broad and on top of the head baldness has started plz suggest me something very good, thnx priti

doctor1 MD

my now 18 year old daughter has experiencing hair thinning you can see to her scalp. and hair looks unhealthy, weight loss, pale, anxiety, moody, depression or low self asteem. we started with vitamins and supplements for the last 4 months but no change. im thinking thyroid? plz. help

doctor1 MD

Hi..have suffered many yers with a ultrarian rapid cycling condition ..I am into a holistic approach to medicine..many years ago I took a coritsol siliva test when I was at my worse ebb ..down.. irritable and feeling dysphoric..I wanted to take this test not when was feeling myself but in this down results the range was 3.5 -9.0 and my results were 1.7..I want to use bioidentical hydrocortisol prepared by a compounding pharmacist ..most doctors do not understand thuis method of treatment but it makes sense ..before I can address the thyroid I need to fix the arfenals first.. thankls for your help..

doctor1 MD

Hi, I have had a fluttery feeling in my throat off and on for a couple of weeks and /or palpitations.Also a sensation that there is something in there or in my upper chest. Heart rate is regular, no other symptoms. I am hypothyroid for many years. It is not severe, just bothers me and I worry what it is.

doctor1 MD

my child is 21 months old and suffeing from constipation from long term. pedistrician told to use some laxatives from 10days as situation got worse ,but still no luck.we did use the back medicine for m otion after 4days while using laxatives. she...

doctor1 MD

My father undergone Electrical cardioversion treatment due to having severe Atrial Fibrilation (AF). Needless to say the treatment did not work after 4 attempts and they have prescribed him various medications to control the rate of the heart. We...

doctor1 MD

I'm a 69 year old female and I'm still getting hot flashes. Doctors say it's something like my internal thermostat is not working. Doesn't sound very specific, does it? A few days ago a hot flash came on and this time the cold sweat was...