Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

123 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

What treatment should be done for breast lump?

Answered by
Dr. Das Arindam

General & Family Physician

Practicing since :2008

Answered : 1416 Questions

Posted on Mon, 7 Jan 2013 in Breast Cancer
Question: The breast lump got trucut biopsy and report cance the oncologist has suggested few test like ER,PR,CErbb2 and ki67 and bone scan test ,after that he will start cemotherapy to kill cancer cells , then once lump reduced in size(presently size is approx is 6cm by 8cm) will operate .'other dr. suggest immediate surgery and then cemo.
we are confused what to do.
pl guide.
Answered by Dr. Das Arindam 1 hour later
Thank you for posting a query.

Firstly, you should provide the total impresseion written at the last part of the biopsy report. This is important.

Some points determine need of neoadjuvant (chemotherapy given before surgery) chemotherapy :
1.     Size more than 5 cm. These tumors have higher chance of recurrence.
2.     Tumor differentiation.
3.     ER / PR expression of the tumor cells. In case of tumor containing cells expressing these receptors, the prognosis is excellent. Early starting of the treatment will help the tumor to reduce in size and help the clinician to detect the proper line of treatment depending upon the response of these hormonal agents. This point is not applicable in tumors expressing low ER / PR.
4.     Her2 Neu expression by the tumor cells. In case of positive tumor, chance of recurrence is greater. So, surgical extension and line of treatment can easily be determined by the clinician depending upon the expression of this marker.

So, in your case, lump is larger than 5cm. But, you have to do the tests for ER, PR, and Her2Neu. these are most important. Erbb2 and ki67 are not important in this stage. But as you have to do immunohistochemistry test on the biopsy slide, it is better to do all these at a time.

Lastly, you really need chemotherapy before surgery depending upon the size only. So, it is better to do the tests, mentioned above and go for chemotherapy before surgery.

Hope this information suffices. Let me know, if you have any more question.


Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,   ,  
Medical Topics

Recent questions on  Brain tumor

doctor1 MD

Helo, my 3 year olf daughter was diagnosed with aggressive non-germinoma Yolk-sac brain tumour at a late stage in the supracellar area. she had surgery then chemo and was growing normally. It was only after the radiation (only to tumour bed) that she stopped growing. I do not what to do? doctors have not given us any growth hormones. She also is aking cortisol hormone as the gland responsible for it does not seem to be working properly, we have been trying to lower the dose but were not able to stop it. Ps: she lost sight in both eyes since tumour was pressing on optic nerves. Can you advise us please?

doctor1 MD

My sister just had an MRI and it states the ill-defined high T@/Flair signal areas in cerebral white matter bilateraly, especially in the frontal lobes. Would you put this in simple terms. She was diagnosed w/a grade II astrocytoma in June 2011 & underwent radiation. Currently on Avastin.

doctor1 MD

My brother is diagnosed with ring enhansing laisons in brain & he is on ATT from last 10 months. But from tomorrow dr has changed his treatment to 2nd line drugs & advised to do brain biopsy.plz suggest me the economical and best institute for brain biopsy...n also tell me the estimated cost of brain biopsy ....I m from Punjab

doctor1 MD

My niece s son has been waking at 5:30am every morning for the last month, vomiting. He is a pre-teen in middle school. He has stopped eating because he doesn t want to vomit anymore, and is losing weight. His doctor has not found a cause for this. His grandfather, my younger brother, died of a brain tumor, a glioma. Is it possible for the grandson to have one also? My daughter had one removed several years ago, also a benign glioma. She was told that they run in families.

doctor1 MD

Hello I am 65 yr old medical history of osteo arthritis brain tumor removal non cancerous acoustic neuroma which left me deaf in my right ear; during the surgery several nerves were damaged during the surgery resulting a stroke: I have 4 nodules...

doctor1 MD

I had a spinal tap they removed some liquid on 11/22 today is the 11/26 and i still have really bad headaches i cant even get up should i go back to the ER?

doctor1 MD

Hellow sir, I am XXXX XXXXXXX from XXXXXXX XXXXXXX My question is "can brain tumour be transferred through mosquitoes?" My neighbour is suffering from brain tumour and there are so many mosquitoes in my area. So, please tell me that brain tumour...