Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

184 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Taking nexium for non reducible hiatal hernia and reflux problem. Should I go for surgery?

Answered by
Dr. Om Lakhani


Practicing since :2004

Answered : 319 Questions

Posted on Thu, 14 Feb 2013 in Digestion and Bowels
Question: I have a moderate sized,sliding,non reducible hiatal hernia and have had reflux problems for 7 years, I take nexium and sometimes when I bend forward I have regurg of acid.On a recent upper GI they identified a schatzki ring as well.
Would surgery be indicated in this type of case?
Answered by Dr. Om Lakhani 2 hours later

The Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons (SAGES) have proposed the following Indications for surgery in GERD:

1) have failed medical management (inadequate symptom control, severe regurgitation not controlled with acid suppression, or medication side effects)


2) opt for surgery despite successful medical management (due to quality of life considerations, lifelong need for medication intake, expense of medications, etc.)


3) have complications of GERD (e.g., Barrett's esophagus, peptic stricture) 18, 19


4) have extra-esophageal manifestations (asthma, hoarseness, cough, chest pain, aspiration)

In your case we can reasonably say that there are some regurgitation symptoms despite medical therapy so you can be considered as a surgical candidate. However practically speaking surgery is generally a personal choice. If you are okay with the symptoms and can deal with the occasional regurgitation, you do not need any surgery, however if you are unhappy with the symptom profile, surgery might help.

Schatzki ring and Hiatus hernia are often seen with GERD and are per-se NOT INDICATIONS FOR SURGERY.

Remember surgery does carry some risk and hence you must discuss with your GI surgeon the risks and benefits of the surgery. As a personal opinion I would advice you against the surgery. What I would advice you apart from your medications is loosing some weight. At 200 lbs loosing a few pounds itself would help you with your GERD.

Hope this answers your question.

Dr. Om Lakhani, MD

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,   ,   ,   ,   ,   ,   ,   ,  
Medical Topics

Recent questions on  Hiatus hernia

doctor1 MD

I am having hiatus hernia.I am taking anticoagulant (Warfarin).Is it risky to undergo surgery for hiatus hernia? I had Pulmonary embolism in2000 and DVT in 2007.So I had to take Warfarin to end of my life. Due to Hiatus hernia my stomach is very big and Iam having GERD problem also.If I make surgery do I get slim stomach and is it risky to undergo surgery?

doctor1 MD

I am a 50 y/o female with a 10 year history of off/on upper abdominal bloating. I had my gall bladder out about a year after it started, but did not affect it. In the last couple of weeks, it has gotten so bad I get short of breath and feel pressure through my neck and face. I was told I had a small hiatal hernia, but last endoscopy and colonoscopy said everything was fine. I have alot of air I burp up, but do not hardly pass any rectal gas. It is like I am making air in my small intestines and it won t move. It feels like a balloon blowing up just inferior of the sternum. Sometimes it feels like it is blocking my great vessel circulation in my abdomen. Do you have any ideas?

doctor1 MD

I ve noticed in increase in my heart rate resting normally I m around 80 bpm now I m 98-99 bpm at rest. Fatigued thru out the day nauseous more often than normal ( I have GERD and a hiatal hernia) .I feel hotter when I m not doing much from my chest up to my face. I m 23 days into my cycle I usually have my period on day 25-27. Little to know premenstural cramps but I usually feel them more when my period is coming but this time not so much. I am sexually active and have been so for almost ten months now with my common law. I can t rely on breast tenderness or soreness as I take Apo-Domperidone for my GERD and the side effect is producing breast milk. Which may account for the heavy feeling in my chest as I did go to the hospital emergency thinking I was having a heart attack, which they kept me over night for tests but nothing was wrong.

doctor1 MD

i been suffering now for 9 months....been to emergecy room 3 times...chest pains...stomach pains.....thought it was heart,but that was cleared with lots of tests....i finally was diagnoised with gerd....had endoscopy....i have acid reflux gerd...small hiatal hernia and duedonitis....iam on nexium now for about 2 months ..has helped somwhat but iam nowhere near back to normal.....this week iam really sick....especially feel bad in hot weather....i have diarhea....stomack aches cramps....but the worst symptom....and i have had it for 9 months is the lightheadeness and dizzyness,,,it feels like iam going to pass out.....i cant even go out to enjoy alo things because i feel like crap....please help

doctor1 MD

I have pain in the center of my chest near the bottom of my ribcage. sometimes it hurts and burns at the same time. I also have several lumps on my chest and in my left breast. they usually don't bother me but when I get cold they hurt until I...

doctor1 MD

Persistent queasiness, espohogeal regurgitation present for over a month plus diarrhea for the as two days. Also, a taste of acid in my mouth 2to 4 hrs after eating. I take 45 mg nexium daily and have no acid reflux . the regurgitation is not acidic.

doctor1 MD

Can this be esophagus cancer or something else? Worried it might be esophagus cancer. Symptoms: 23 year old male, about 1.6 (1 year and 6 months ago), upper endoscopy was done with no esophagitis , normal biopsy of esophagus. Hiatus hernia was...