Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

152 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Suggested immobilization for broken arm. Having severe pain. What cure should be done?

Answered by
Dr. Sudhir

Internal Medicine Specialist

Practicing since :2000

Answered : 1417 Questions

Posted on Mon, 7 Jan 2013 in Bones, Muscles and Joints
Question: My closest friend, a 61 year old woman broke her arm 11 months ago in a fall. She wanted the doctor to operate and put a pin in it but instead they recommended immobilization. It took longer to hear than normal due to her taking a drug for osteoporosis but it has now healed. However she complains of blinding pain. Her husband has had to quit work to look after her as she is completely unable to do anything. She cries constantly from the pain. She is extremely angry that she did not get the "right treatment" at the time. I can not stand to call or visit her any more because she lays on the couch and cries from the pain alternating with ranting that her husband and doctor made the wrong decision (in her mind) in immobilizing the arm. Is there any possibility that this is physical or is she suffering from a mental illness.
Answered by Dr. Sudhir 21 minutes later

I guess it's more of misunderstanding on part of your friend.Generally doctors consider many factors before suggesting treatment and patient might not be aware of the facts.So a good discussion with her doctor can help her understand why particular treatment was selected. Results of treatment are not always predictable and treatment selection is always done in good faith.This would be first step.

Second step is to investigate her for the pain.A broken healed fracture should not cause so much pain.There might be other injury associated with this which might cause so much pain.Injuries which need to be ruled out are pinched/injured nerve, torn ligament or tendon etc. A healed fracture should not cause debilitating pain.

I know it would be difficult for her to understand as she is in severe pain but this things can help her.And in such cases generally there are both physical and mental elements involved.With good discussions, support, understanding and treatments she should feel better.

For time being doctor can put her on higher painkillers.

Hope this answers your question.

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar
Follow up: Dr. Sudhir 20 hours later
Thank you I found your answer very comprehensive and understanding.

The question I now have is what could be the reason why she is prevented from taking any painkillers.

As far as I or anyone else knows she is not taking anything at all for the pain.

The only reason I can imagine that she can not take painkillers is that she has liver damage.

She told me that she could not take any pain killer because it interfered with healing. I understand that one does not take noninflammatories immediately after a broken bone and maybe when the bone was healing slowly someone got the idea that not taking painkillers might speed the process. ... but it is now healed.

She now is telling other people she is allergic to opiates but I know she has taken Tylenol three all her life and she has never told me she was allergic to opiates.

I imagine it is possible to develop an allergy or a low level allergy to become worse but there must be something else that would help.

I am feeling particularly guilty because her husband has complained that I am abandoning her after years of friendship and also I received a phone call l from other friends saying she feels abandoned by me. In turn I am being told that her husband looks terrible due to the pressure of caring for her.

I am not squeamish about ill people because i am an estates planning lawyer and visit dying and ill people constantly. But I have not experienced anything like this before where a person is alternately crying and ranting for 11 months.

I considered having a psychologist visit her with me, but the psychologists advice to me was that my withdrawal was self protective and perhaps necessary to my mental health when faced with an intractable problem i don;t understand.
Answered by Dr. Sudhir 5 hours later
Thanks for follow up question.

Common causes of not taking painkillers are allergy, compromised liver/kidney function or side effects. But still there are medications that can be taken in these cases. So her doctor after evaluation and detailed history can suggest painkiller medications for her.A appropriate medications can surely help her.

In my view your friend is in self pity and attention seeking phase. She is doing it by not taking medications, complaining and exaggerating pain. Such patients always want to show their suffering and continuously complain about people close to them. A good counseling can prove helpful in her case.
I agree with your psychologist and your approach of withdrawal. I think you should keep visiting her, but keep visits short and don’t think about it when you are away. Don’t evaluate yourself by opinions of others, just give support as much as you can and don’t get stressed out.

Hope my answer helps you.


Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions
Drug/Medication ,  

Recent questions on  Tylenol

doctor1 MD

I think I might have had a mini stroke a few days ago. I did not go to DR no health ins. Hot flash, dizziness blindness in left eye like a bright flash bulb light lasted over an hour. Nausea, lethargic, no appetite. Numbness in right hand and difficulty writing - also right hand. Estrace for hormone replacement from historectomy 2m daily. Tylenol PM to sleep nightly. Forty seven years old, 115lbs, 5 10 YYYY@YYYY

doctor1 MD

Hi Doctor, My 8 months old son has been having loose motion since last Saturday. He had sever diaper rashes which has now reduced to some extent. Last Wednesday he had high temperature in the night (102 degree F) after which we started Tylenol. From Friday, he started developing rashes all over his body including his face. His fever has come down, but all the remaining symptoms are still there. Please advice what could be the cause for this.

doctor1 MD

I am currently on Tramadol for a pain that I haven t been able to get rid of on my own with relaxation and OTC meds such as Tylenol and Advil. Tonight my heart has been palpitating and I want to know if it could be the pain pill or if not is it safe to take the Tramadol?

doctor1 MD

If Naproxen has damaged my kidneys and Tylenol is bad for my liver what type of pain meds are available for me? I am said to have several chronic conditions which Docs seem to think or they claim once thought were in people s heads, which I don t understand, but I m only a teacher with a BS and a MS who suffers from spinal degeneration, narrowing of the spine, bulges at L1 and L2 and recently L4 and L5 up until Oct. 2013 when an attempt was made to correct these imaginary disc bulges. I suffer daily sinus headaches docs say they see something in there but there s nothing they can do about it. I have bursitis they tell me, which at times calls for a long needle to be jabbed into my hip and, there s nothing imaginary about that. They tell me I have Gerd so I imagine that s that burning sensation that come up in my chest and throat when I miss taking my omeprazole. I wonder if something like that could have led to my moms and her only sister s esophageal cancer? Or it could be the hiatal hernia or the unspecified intestinal disease they told me I have. You know I thought after that surgery while I was in rehab I was feeling better then I had in years and then I went home. The very next day I was back in the emergency room oh I forgot before I left the rehab a sore started to form at the surgical site and it began to bleed a little but no one was alarmed, especially not me I had had at least 8 abdominal surgeries before, one of them had to ripped back open due to infection (my C-section) the other burst back open when I was made to get up and too soon I thought, after my hysterectomy when I became dizzy and fell while walking down the hospital hallway. This was different this was something I had never heard of and probably would not have if I had died you see doc the people in the emergency room sent me home with a tube of cream, never contacted my surgeon it was her day off never advised a follow-up with her, oh I guess they knew I would not need one. But because I had home health care they took me to their hospital and a week later from the doctor s office I was rushed into surgery stat still didn t know what was wrong and two operations later after efforts to get my blood pressure stabilized I was then told I had contracted something called MRSA. I was on antibiotics for months and sick as hell for months one infection in the body after another in various places I won t name. Finally I was treated for a terrible bronchitis that would only go away with a protocol of prednisone and antibiotics used to treat pneumonia. So back to my original what type of pain meds are safe for me? Thank you in advance if you can answer my question and God bless.

doctor1 MD

My 2 year old grand daughter is staying with me. She only gets a fever of 104 at night. IN the day it is normal and she goes throgh her normal routine, active and eats and drinks well. In the evening, she is drigining and eating snacks too. My...

doctor1 MD

Hey doctor this morning before work I had a blood test done. There was not much pain during it but afterwards I was in a bit of a rush since I had to go to work straight after and in the rush I noticed pain in my left arm where the blood was drawn...

doctor1 MD

Getting tatoo in couple hours. Is it ok to take tylenol & flexeril before and or after tatoo? Thanks for prompt help!