Get your Health question answered in 3 easy steps

159 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Suggest ways to diagnose COPD

Answered by
Dr. Shashi Dangwal


Practicing since :1979

Answered : 1126 Questions

Posted on Mon, 11 Aug 2014 in Lung and Chest disorders
Question: Approximately 8 years ago I was taken to the hospital with labored breathing. An ER doctor who had never seen me nor had copies of my medical records stated I had COPD (because I use to smoke more than 10 years prior to that visit. ) My regular doctor prescribed Advair Disk Inhaler and a Pro air rescue inhaler to be taken the rest of my life. I am now 68 and have taken this medication since I was 57. On a recent visit to my primary care physician I ask if I should be referred to a specialist because I had never taken a breathing test. My doctor said no and I cannot personally make an appointment to see a pulmonary specialist without his referral. I am confused as to why? I thought your lungs was one of the few organs that could heal themselves.
Answered by Dr. Shashi Dangwal 3 hours later
Brief Answer:
Impress on your doctor your keeness and need to v

Detailed Answer:

Thanks for posting your query on HCM.

Diagnosis of COPD is normally made on the basis of symptoms and history of smoking. You may have been a reformed smoker but you can still develop COPD. After smoking cessation, though further damage to the lungs may stop but the damage that has already occurred heals very gradually and in some, the lung function may never come back to normal.

Having said that, I`m of the opinion that when the diagnosis of COPD was made, the ER doctor or your regular doctor should have asked for a spirometry(breathing test) or should have referred you to a pulmonologist to know your lung function and to confirm the diagnosis.

I feel that with continued absence and regular treatment your lung function may have improved considerably. I`m not aware of the medical practices in your part of the world but I feel if you desire to consult a specialist and want a particular test, you should not be denied that as it`s your basic right and freedom of choice. I can only suggest that you should again impress on your doctor your keeness and need to visiting a specialist.
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar
Follow up: Dr. Shashi Dangwal 12 hours later
Is chronic broncitus also blamed on smoking since it also falls under the umbrella of COPD ?
Answered by Dr. Shashi Dangwal 16 hours later
Brief Answer:
Yes, chronic bronchitis is one of the two diseases

Detailed Answer:

Yes, chronic bronchitis is one of the two diseases grouped under COPD, other being Emphysema and smoking has been proved to be the cause for it beyond doubts.
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,   ,   ,  
Medical Topics

Recent questions on  Emphysema

doctor1 MD

Over past several months.Mom (79 years old - now about 88 lbs) started w/ shortness breathe - expected w/ and fatigue CPOD(just say lung dr first time - stage 4 emphysema) Nov.. diarrhea for several days & ankles swollen before convinced to go to clinic... Blood work showed anemia, albumin and protein levels off, no blood in stool..oxygen levels were in mid 50s..xray showed fluid in chest...antibiotics , oxygen helped her feel better..oxygen levels remain in low - mid 90s she is on it most of the time....started feeling bad and diarrhea back...being cultured for c diffe..... would it be wrong of me to ask about whipple's disease? only thing I see online that has all her symptoms...or will the culture pick it up if it is the cause? usually don't search out online but frustrated at not finding the cause of diarrhea in conjunction to other problems

doctor1 MD

ive just been told i have tachnacardia high pulse rate. im on bp meds but doesnt help lower pulse rate which is usually over hundred. can this be controlled with meds or is surgery required? im 65 about 50# overweight and have copd with emphysema and plaque in the corotid arteries but no narrowing. im on nebulizer breathing meds also. i have severe ucerated esophagus which is under control.

doctor1 MD

Hi I have discomfort in breathing fully.I can breathe, but only with discomfort. I feel that its just my left lung which makes it difficult to breathe. It happens only sporadically throughout the day. No other symptoms. Could it be A1AD? and what are foods rich in A1A?

doctor1 MD

My aunt was admitted to the hospital and they found swelling around her heart and lungs a week ago. She was transferred to a different hospital today and the tests show that she has leakage in her aeortic and mitral valves. She is 72 years years old and they are recommending surgery.She also has emphysema. How soon should she have surgery? What are the risks with having the surgery or not having the surgery? Despite her smoking she is in good health. She eats a healthy diet and exercises regularly.

doctor1 MD

I have been diagnosed with emphysema . Pain in my chest and always in my left arm. Sometimes the pain is excruciating. I have a lot of saliva during the painful periods. Cold air (45 and below seem to trigger it quicker). None of the meds given...

doctor1 MD

I am having a strange issue. First off I am an off and on iv drug user of methamphetamine . And a little background I'm 30 y/o and have no known illnesses except hsv1 and heterozygous factor v Leiden . I take prescribed med clonazepam as needed no...

doctor1 MD

I am in the final stages of Emphysema . What is my prognosis. I do not cough or spit up sputim.How many weeks/months to I have left