Get your Health question answered in 3 easy steps

156 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 18 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Screw fitted to repair a torn ligament. Noticed swelling, pain and numbness. Looking for cure

Answered by
Dr. Rajesh Gajwani

Orthopaedic Surgeon

Practicing since :1975

Answered : 72 Questions

Posted on Tue, 18 Dec 2012 in Back Pain
Question: Three years ago I had a screw put in big knuckle on index finger to repair a torn ligament. Surgery went well, repair great. I developed lots and lots of scar tissue which resulted in constant swelling, pain, and loss of motion. Last year they went back in and cleaned out the site and freed up the tendon that was a bit bound from scarring. During surgery I had 100% range of motion, up from the 40% before I went in. About a month into physical therapy things started to go down hill. Same thing, constant swelling, pain and losing motion. Now, a year later, I have very little motion, my index finger naturally stays a bit bent, I have pain and constant swelling. I have had an ultra sound, xray and mri. Things look good except for the inflammation and thickening. I have been to my surgeon and two other hand specialists to see if anyone can figure this out. No answers. Then I suddenly realized that I have had reactions to metals in the past. Jewlery, snaps on pants, etc. Went to allergist. Very allergic to nickel. She said my knuckle is most likely an allergic reaction to the nickle in the implant which I now know only contains 1-2% nickel. Surgeon says he doesn't know for sure and the only way to find out it to remove the screw. He also says he has found no other reason for my present condition so maybe that is the reason. Trying to decide if it's worth it to go through the surgery and the painful, long recovery again. I am an active 50 year old woman. I do landscaping for work and my hand hurts every day. i go to the gym and can't wrap my finger around weights. Also when there is any pressure on the underside of knuckle, like using a shovel or holding weights, it is very painful and sometimes get numbness in finger. Just looking for more insight on my issues to help me decide about surgery. Thanks.
Answered by Dr. Rajesh Gajwani 2 hours later
Thanks for your query.

After reading your symptoms, i feel that it seems to be a metal allergy case as mentioned in your history as well. In my opinion the screw should have been removed earlier during the second surgery.
I would strongly suggest that you get it removed immediately to reduce pain and further discomfort. After the removal of the screw you must start physiotherapy after a gap of 15 days.
Wish you a speedy recovery.

Do let me know if you have any other queries.

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Aparna Kohli
Follow up: Dr. Rajesh Gajwani 5 hours later
Thank you. Have you done this procedure or know about any that were performed. What was the outcome? I have been looking online on the web for any write ups about this condition and haven't been able to find anything that really relates to me. I found plenty on heart stints but nothing just specific to reaction right around screw in a hand. Can you guide me to any info? In my decision to have surgery it would be reassuring to be able to read or hear about any successes or failures with this procedure relating specifically to the metal allergy. Thanks.
Answered by Dr. Rajesh Gajwani 13 hours later

Yes, I have done this procedure a couple of times before with successful results. But metal allergy was not the case with those patients. Still the procedure is the same and should not have any issues.
I am certain it can be handled without too much difficulty.

Metal allergy may be the cause for your problem; but surgery for screw removal is done commonly with decent results.

I do not have any write ups pertaining to metal allergy to share but I am fairly certain that it is the right treatment plan in your case.

Hope this suffices. I will be available for further discussion if needed.


Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Prasad

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Lab Tests ,   ,  

Recent questions on MRI

doctor1 MD

my daughter has recently been diagnosed with idiopathis scoliosis, she has 2 50 degree bends plus a twist in the middle, she seems to have got worse and is not suffering from sharp pains at the base of her skull up into her head, she is scheduled for surgery but we are waiting on mri scan to rule out underlying issues, she has asymmetric tummy, should i be concerned and speak to the surgeon with these pains

doctor1 MD

I recently had an MRI done for leg numbness and pain also very limited movement to lift my right leg, I have an appointment this coming wk with an ortho Dr. shows some bulging and minor tear in L3-4 plus alot of other things. Also what concerns me more is evaluated lesions at the right kidney, which when I was called with the MRI results this was not mentioned. My father had a kidney remove because of cancer , should I be concaened and should I insist on follow up care.

doctor1 MD

Hello Doctor, My dad 58 is suffering from bone tb in cervical region (C5,C6,C7), he developed weakness in legs and coudnt walk w/o support. Initially he was treated by ortho who put him on 4 drug ATT and performed a minor operation of draining pus but his condition worsened after operation (paraplegic Complete motor and sensory loss in legs, no sense of bladder ) and was refrred to a neurosurgeon. He was operated again and decompression and bone grafting was performed, after one month also his condition did not improve and an MRI was taken again. Doctor said that there is a degeneration in the vertebrae which forms lower part of the graft and the screws were displaced from their position and were causing compression of spinal cord. He was again operated and the graft was removed(by a different doctor). Doctor said that due to multiple operations he has become weak and said that will keep him under observation for sometime and if required operation can be performed after a month. Meanwhile my dad has problem swollowing which was not there after 2 previous operations. He was put on complete bed rest by the previous 2 doctors but this doctor makes him sit for 5 min daily and has also said that will try to make him sit on wheel chair in some days. My question: Is my dad being treated the right way?

doctor1 MD

Am querying current line of thinking by several consultants. Admitted to hospital May 2011; lumbar puncture showed elevated CSF protein of 1088 mg/L with 228 white cells, 95% lymphocytes. The working diagnosis was viral meningitis, and I was discharged after 2 days aciclovir. Negative for herpes simplex virus 1 and 2. Developed infection in leg early October 2011, followed by painful groin, then ulcers either side of scrotum - non painful, and diagnosed as shingles. Mid October 2011, following tinitus, buzzing , hearing different frequencies, then vertigo, admitted for 2 weeks in ID ward...CSF showed 614 white cells with 90% lymphocytosis. CSF protein raised at 1335 mg/L. Tested for everything under the sun, incl. HIV, syphillis, Lyme disease, Cat scratch fever (leg infection thought to have been through an insect bite). All negative, incl. ANA. Chest x-ray, MRI scan of brain and whole spine also negative. Admitted again 26th December 2011, aciclovir for seven days, now back home feeling well, if a little tired. Current thought is Mollarets meningitis, but more recently, rheumatology dept. thinking Behcets syndrome, as I suffer from mouth ulcers. My contention is this; I have sufferd from mouth ulcers since a teenager taking exams at school. If I have a job interview, I will get mouth ulcers after @ 48 hours. Dentist thinks stress induced, as do I. I have no aching joints and no eye irritation, also, just found out that HLAB51 negative. I am a 42 year old British male and caucasian. I can t help feeling there s a square peg being pushed into a round hole here. What about migraine; the tinitus, buzzing and vertigo? Also, I took a non-steroidal (Ibuprofen) prior to the first two episodes. Bickerstaff s encephalitis sounds just as plausible as Behcets...or am I in denial? I would appreciate any advice, even if it s to simply face the music . Thank you for your time.

doctor1 MD

For past 12+ hours, I’ve had left side pain from left pectoral up through left shoulder and down my left arm to my hand. Sharpest pain is in shoulder, elbow and dorsal side of forearm. Some twitching in wrist and hand.

doctor1 MD

I had a discectomy and I woke up in excruciating pain. A week later a laminectomy to stop the pain. Epidural injection,Morhine, Dilaudid , nothing helps. Something does not seem right. My Dr. has released me and says it will take a year to get...

doctor1 MD

I have been diagnosed with spondylothesis of the L5 and S1 region. I have had an mri and x-rays for my back. I had an epidural injection(2) in Nov in my back which seemed to help the pain going down my legs for a couple of weeks. Unfortunately I...