Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

159 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Is lying about the severity of a patient's condition and treatment details ethical?

Answered by
Dr. Panagiotis Zografakis

Internal Medicine Specialist

Practicing since :1999

Answered : 675 Questions

Posted on Tue, 21 Mar 2017 in Medicines and Side Effects
Question: Can doctors legally and per their ethical responsibility/scope of practicce , lie to a vulnerable and terrified patient under their care about what medications that vulnerable and desperate patient is given using deception as a method to administer a drug/drugs that the patient specifically listed as causing severe and even life threatening side affects? When injury and emotional damage results from this type of situation, what is a patient to do? How can I better protect myself from this type of abuse?
Answered by Dr. Panagiotis Zografakis 15 minutes later
Brief Answer:
normally no doctor should lie to a patient

Detailed Answer:

a doctor should always tell the truth about the patient's condition and treatment details including the risks involved and the expected benefit. The only exception may involve incapacitated patients due to mental illness or dementia.

The only way to protect yourself against such behavior is to choose your doctor carefully. Some patients want their doctors to guide them without providing the details. In case your doctor thinks you're such a patient, you can emphasize your need to participate in treatment decisions.

Kind Regards!

Kind Regards!
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions

Recent questions on  Dementia

doctor1 MD

Is microvascular leukoencephalopathy progressive? My mother had an MRI done in 2007 showing white matter disease, subcortical atrophy and small vessel disease. Over the past 6-7 years she had been falling in the house and I noticed after the falling she had been experiencing some forgetfulness. She has been to a neurologist about 5 years ago and he had given her a mini-mental state test, and sent her for neuropsych testing. She also suffers from renal insufficiency due to hypertension (she is in Stage 3). She was in stage 4 but a nephrologist has her in stage 3 due to the right medications. Her mother had died from uremic poisoning over 50 years ago (no dialysis then). Anyway, the neurologist based on his examinations and testing feels that she is in a mild to moderate stage of alzheimer. Her cardiologist told me that she has microvascular leukoencepahlopaty (she also has hardenining of the arteries). Her primary care physician feels that her dementia is microvascular (AKA vascular due to small vessel disease; she also has diabetes, coronary artery disease, hypertension, hypothyroidism, cholesterol.) She was a smoker, but stopped about 17 years ago. She also has perepheral artery disease. She is on many medications including aricept and namenda. She also experiences parkinson-like tremors. She had a eeg showing a slows of speech language done about 4 years ago. Based on what I have told you is this dementia of a vascular origin, or is it a mixed dementia? She is currently 86 years old and resides in a nursing home. I know I witnessed while she was at home some forgetfulness like leaving a stove on, poor hygiene, moods swings (verbally and hitting). Also, she would have auditory & visual hallucinations (hearing music, talking to imaginary people). I thought at this point she would be better in a facility where she is exposed to people her age and mind stimulation would be more available than staying at home with a home health aide. She had a sister who had passed away last year at 83 years old from alzheimer. Could both sisters have the same thing? I know her sister had hypertension and atrial fib.

doctor1 MD

my 84 yr old mother who has moderate to severe vascular dementia has tmo leaky heart valves. she has already had a valve replaced 5 yrs ago which although successful increased her dementia a lot so surgery not an option. how long do you think my mums lifespan will be?

doctor1 MD

Hello, My mother has dementia and is already established in a proper care home, what I would like to ask is this, would it be detremental to her well being if she was moved 100 miles to another home just because a family member wanted her to be nearer ti them ??

doctor1 MD

Hi, my grandmother is 90 years old and she has suffered with dementia for the past eight or nine months. My uncle is her caregiver and he abruptly removed her from her condo as a result of a doctor visit where the doctor told him that she should not live alone. He did not realize that she was on medication for a thyroid condition and had not given it to her in six months. She loss over forty pounds. The problem that we have now is that she is taking her thyroid medicine, but she refuses to eat. She was recently hospitalized for not eating and the doctor recommended either a feeding tube or a blood transfusion due to her being an anemic. My quesiton is how do I get my grandmother to eat? She is back home but she has bed sores and soreness of her back because she was in the hospital for almost three weeks.

doctor1 MD

I would like to try Huperzine A for my husband who has early onset dementia . Have you ever suggested this supplement safely to anyone before?

doctor1 MD

What is involved in testing for Alzheimer's?

doctor1 MD

Currently taking Zonegram for migraines, lexapro for mild depression and cymbalta for mild depression a anxiety . along with adderall for years i have been complaining of not being able to find words, and forgetfullness. I was tested about 1 year...