Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

122 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Is Methylin ER effective in treatment of severe ADHD?

Answered by
Dr. Sunil Gupta


Practicing since :2005

Answered : 637 Questions

Posted on Sat, 30 Aug 2014 in Child Health
Question: My granddaughter has been diagnosed with severe ADHD. What do you know about the drug Methylin ER? I hear from some parents that with stimulant drugs that the time of efficacy is important. Most parents are recommending Vyvanse since it has a long time being effectivd ( 12 hours or 13) compared to Attenrol which is 8 hours. Doctor wants to start on that and if she has mania type systems they can discontinue right away and the would go to Strattera which takes longer to be noticed in system. What is your opinion? She is 16 and very bright ( all ap classes) but unable to do class work in her Sophmore year despite being third in state competition in debate. Lots of sommatic issues and not going to school, anxiety, withdrawn. Has a small circle of friends.
Answered by Dr. Sunil Gupta 4 hours later
Brief Answer:
Please see details below

Detailed Answer:

I went through your query in detail and can understand your concern regarding your granddaughter's condition and her medications.

Methylin ER is extended release formulation of meythlphenydate and Vyvanse is lisdexamfetamine dimesylate. Both are stimulants which are effective mediations for ADHD. Strattera and Attentrol are both the same drug containing Atomoxetine which is also one of the treatment option of ADHD.

In general, methylphenydate and amphetamines are the first line treatment options of ADHD. Both are effective drugs. In general, the extended release version of methylphenydate as well as Vyvanse are both long acting and used as once daily dose. Both are equally effective as well. However, it has been seen that the effects of Vyvanse lasts slightly longer and the patients don't experience much ups and downs in the symptoms. However, mostly the effects differ from patient to patient.

In general, we start with any one of the stimulants and if the patient is fine with it and responds well, continue with the same. In case of any problems or side effects, we can shift to some other stimulant.

In comparison, Atomoxetine is found to slightly less effective than methylphenydate and amphetamine salts and considered if the stimulants are not tolerated well. It is usually the second line drug fro ADHD.

Your psychiatrist is just being careful about using the stimulants because of family history of bipolar disorder. Stimulants just might increase the chance of inducing mania and it is good that your psychiatrist is careful and observant about any such possibility.

Regarding time taken for reply, usually it varies and can be few minutes to few hours depending on when your question is picked up the the specialist that you have chosen.

I do hope that I was able to answer your query. Please let me know if you have any further queries.

I wish a speedy recovery for your granddaughter.

Best wishes.

Dr. Sunil Gupta

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions
Drug/Medication ,   ,   ,   ,   ,  

Recent questions on  Methylin

doctor1 MD

I am 23 and in law school currently. I was diagnosed with ADHD about 5 or 6 years ago. I took Concerta (54 mg) just about the entire time. Recently (last few weeks) my doctor changed to Methylin (20 mg/day) because insurance was giving us problems with Concerta. The Methylin really did not do anything for me. I saw my primary care physician in December, and discussed this. I told her side effects from the Concerta (cannot sleep, no appetite, mood swings, etc. common from what I have read about Concerta). She then wanted me to try 20 mg of Methylin in the morning, 10 mg in the evening because of the long days I need to be focused in law school. Anyway, getting to the point of my question (I wanted to provide background the best I could). Since I have switched, I have actually found the new medicine to work. It is not as, umm not sure how else to put this but, punch you in the face, like Concerta can be. It is more even throughout the dosage. BUT, I have been having terrible, terrible headaches since I have been taking it. On the bottle, it says that is a side effect. I am wondering if this is a normal side effect. If this is normal, is there anyway to stop it aside from taking Tylenol, Advil, etc.? They usually do not even touch it. I take 2 rapid release Tylenol, and another about an hour later because it is still killing me. Should I see a doctor or is this completely normal?

doctor1 MD

My granddaughter is going to take the adhd drug Methylin 10 mgs starting tomorrow. There is no information on the google search about the questimated time of efficacy. Vyvanse has thqt information on line. Can you clarify if Methylin wears off...

doctor1 MD

I have been taking methylphenidate for quite a long time and I am having trouble with the short wash out time. My doctor gave me an rx for Methylphenidate ER and it has no stimulant result. In fact, I fall asleep very soon after my dose. What do...