Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

186 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Is Belviq safe to take to lose weight?

Answered by
Dr. Shafi Ullah Khan

General & Family Physician

Practicing since :2012

Answered : 3614 Questions

Posted on Sat, 2 Aug 2014 in General Health
Question: I am 5'9 and weight 268; female age 36. I have put on about 10 pounds every year for the past 10 years. I have already been tested for diabetes and thyroid and all my labs always come back normal. But, no matter what I do, I can't lose weight. I like exercise and have lost a couple of pounds since December by tracking steps with a pedometer/fitbit, but I just can't get the weight to come off. It seems my problem is just...I am always hungry, even after a meal. I had read about Belviq and would like to give it a try. I called 3 doctors in town and they are just bariatric surgeons - so it was like, they were interested only in surgical options. I would like to give Belviq a try, but don't know how to get a prescription. Can you please help me? I never thought I would contact an online doctor, but here I am.
Answered by Dr. Shafi Ullah Khan 5 hours later
Brief Answer:
online prescriptions not valid

Detailed Answer:
Thank you for asking
I can understand your concern but i am sorry to say that online prescriptions are not valid and we doctors at HCM do not do that. Not just us but any one don't do that online due to FDA portals are just for education and guidance purpose only.that Is why very answer is followed by a disclaimer mentioning the nature of this answer and limitations to it.but I can guide you and give you some tips regarding losing weight.

Obesity is a very worrisome health crisis not only in states but all over the world. 36 % people are obese, and 50 % plus amongst rest are overweight.78 million adults who are more than age 20 (which include 37.5 million men and 40.6 million women) and 12.5 million children and adolescents age (5.5 million boys and 7 million girls) in the United States are obese with men and women 36 % prevalent( 36 among every 100) 17 % 17 among every 100 children and adolescents.

Lets talk what are the reasons a person get obese. Genetic , metabolic, activity levels, hormonal derangements, race type, sex common in males and in women pst menopausal, age related increment, ethnic and cultural issues, socioeconomic statuses ( previously used to be called the illness of rich people), Habits of eating, Cessation of smoking ( odd but a truth – no way a reason to continue smoking though), pregnancies in women, psychologic issues like bulimia etc, diabetes and gestational diabetes etc, lactation and breastfeeding etc, are some of the many reasons for the crime of obesity.

Amongst them all, inactivity and sedentary lifestyles are the most common troubles. less than half people amongst world meet the physical guidelines of active lifestyles, rest are sedentary as snails and lethal to themselves as a bomb. Even high school kids are inactive and every 7 out of 10 highschoolers are inactive and thus implants the ticking time bomb.

Now lets talk who is obese, who is morbidly obese and who is overweight and who is normal.

To know that calculate your BMI here

If you stand below 25 you are fine.

if between 25 and 29.9 then you are overweight

if above 30 and below 39.9 then obese

and if above 40 then morbid obesity is your category which you should not be proud of.

The more the BMI the more the odds for associated morbidities like coronary heart diseases, diabetic neuropathies, vasculopathies etc.

If you are above 40 the age odds increase by 20 years in men and 5 years in women.

Enough jibber jabber about the obesity. Now lets talk about the management and ways to combat it.

A good start is always a modification in diet and lifestyle. self monitoring of caloric intake, stimulus control, non food rewards, relapse prevention, seeking dietitian help etc.

Sign up to a weight loss program under an FDA approved clinician with realistic goals and expectations regarding weight loss.

I call them SMART: Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Realistic, and Timely.Before signing up to programs evaluation for psychiatric morbidities is a must do procedure to sort out depression, eating disorders, not complying will lead to drastic effects and changes in lifestyle and personality which one would regret for long time.

Now what should be the goal and target? it is usually recommended to lose weight at a pace of 1-2 pounds per week and faster than this can lead to issues inevitable. maximum of 10 % of the weight or more precise 30 pounds is to be reduced in one program on 12 weeks maximum followed by a break with try to maintain the loss for at least a year and then trying further.

Remember losing weight is easy. maintaining the loss is a challenge. and to do that one needs self monitoring of weight, low fat diet intake, daily exercise of at least 60 minutes with no breaks, minimum sedentary time in life like watching TV or bed ridden habits. Diet induced weight loss increases the hunger and appetite and creates a challenge for the patient and the perseverance and patience is tested otherwise rep lapse occurs and all effort goes in vane. And this applies to every age group but children more specific as their lifespan matters the most here.

Energy expenditures are obsolete these days as metabolism varies, usually 22 kilo calories are required for every kg to be maintained therefore  weight loss reduces the expenditure and dampen the pace of loss which most of the time disappoints the patient and then they commit the cheap publicity damaging stunts to be a super man in one day , time when they lose it.Also every decade / 10 years reduce the 100kcals consumption in a body so old people need more effort to lose the same weight as does the adult does , men lose more than women at the same effort.

What to eat, what not to eat how to eat how much to eat and when to eat are some very import an questions need to be answered.

Low fat diets like Ornish diets, Low carbohydrate diets like Atkin diets and Medievel diets like zone diets in which all three major nutrients of carbohydrates, fats and proteins are used in equal proportion , JOLSIN WHY WAIT diet for diabetic patients( 40-65 % carbohydrates, 20-30 % fats and less than 35 % fats) are some of the diets clinicians recommend for obesity.

these are balanced. low calories and reduced-portion sized diets recommended by dieticians

portion control can be attained by getting involved in  weight loss programs like  Jenny XXXXXXX Nutrisystem or by the use of products such as meal-replacement shakes, bars, prepackaged meals, and frozen entrees (eg, Slim-Fast, Glucerna, Lean Cuisine, Healthy Choice, Smart Ones). These have adequate and enough amounts of the major diet components based on the food pyramid from the US Department of Agriculture and recommended daily allowances (RDAs). These sources also have adequate micro components of nutrition and trace elements like vitamins and minerals etc.

Alcohol, sodas, most fruit juices, and highly concentrated sweets are generally calorie dense and nutrient deficient (so-called empty calories). therefore, these are generally prohibited and to be avoided or reduced to a minimum levels of possible.

If you keep the calories intake in the range of 500-1000 kcal/ day ro 800-1800 kcal/day , you will start losing weight at a pace of 1-2 pounds ( 0.4-0.5 kg) every week. ideal loss in 10 – 20 pounds for 200 pounds person over 3- 6 months.

if you try more faster than this you will develop complications like Vitamin deficiency, starvation ketosis, electrolyte derangements and gall bladder stones etc are some amongst them. keep preteens in range of .8 to 1.5 per kg do not exceed 100 gm. carbohydrates maximum 50 gram per day, water drinking of more than 1000 ml or minimum of 6 glasses,

it is said that drinking cold water 10ml per kg ( e.g. 700 ml / 3 glasses for 70 kg man) before every meal accelerates thew weight loss and makes it easy. so make a habit of drinking water before meal.

Last but not the least way is exercise. Intensive exercise programs work like charm but cardiac and respiratory profiles need to be evaluated first before prescribing them. Aerobic isotonic exercises are the best amongst all. Ideal is 30 – 60 minutes a day 5 – 7 imps a week. Anaerobic isometric exercises, resistant training can be used as side technique but with a lot of monitoring.

Modify behaviour before its to late, never sleep for more than 7 to 8 hours..sleeping less than 6 and more than 9 hours are both lethal and a great addition to obesity. so balance of sleep is advised and any extreme would exaggerate the obesity issue.

Now the list of medications prescribed in obesity but to be used only after consulting a physicians and let them choose what is best.

  Lorcaserin Belviq

 Phentermine/topiramate (Qsymia)

Phentermine (Adipex-p, Ionamin, Suprenza) 

Diethylpropion (Tenuate, Tenuate Dospan)

Phendimetrazine (Bontril,Bontril PDM, Adphen, Aplhazine,Phenazine )

Benzphetamines (Didrex)

Orlistat (Xenical, Alli)

There are many products like above mentioned available over the counter with out prescription like ephedrine, caffeine, benzocaine, chromium, psyllium, chitosan, and herbal preparations. Herbal ingredients frequently include ma huang (Ephedra sinica), St. John’s wort (Hypericum perforatum), guarana (Paulinia cupana), kola nut (Cola nitida, Cola acuminata, and Garcinia cola), hydroxycitric acid (Garcinia cambogia) etc.

Bariatric Surgeries are new development and advised to BMIs above 40 or people in old age where exercise is not an option for weight loss

Before going for any drug, remember one thing. Every Drug Is A Poison And Every Poison Is A Drug. Its the expertise of a physician which avoids the misuse. Self treating and self medicating will help no way but create more chaos
I hope it helps.take care and don't forget to close the discussion please.
may the odds be ever in your favour.

Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions ,   ,  
Medical Topics ,   ,  

Recent questions on  Gestational diabetes

doctor1 MD

this past year i had my first child. and gained forty pounds which put me at 270. i had gestational diabetes but not any symptoms since. but lately while doing nothing i will feel my heart rate increase rapidly for a few seconds. what could be the cause?

doctor1 MD

is it normal to have bowel trouble after having a c- section, i had one 4 months ago to deliver twins and since then i've had problems with wind and gotta go when i feel the urge! my gp told me it was my body readjusting to a normal diet as i had gestational diabetes in pregnancy. but surely it would have adjusted by now

doctor1 MD

Hi Doctor my wife is 25 weeks pregnant. We recently got RBS GCT Test on empty stomach with 50mg glucose[1 hour after] for her. results are a follows: 190 mg/dl Please suggest the demerits of having this level and also advice methods to reduce the...

doctor1 MD

I'm experiencing extreme stomach pain! It's right in the area of my sternum (middle upper where my ribs come together). Other symptoms are Diareah with mucous and a little blood in stool . I have no energy and feel dizzy and naucious and my skin...

doctor1 MD

Hi, Is it better to take tums for indigestion/IBS or a proton inhibitor like Dexilant? Please note that I am a high risk patient for osteoporosis and diabetes, based on family history and gestational diabetes .

doctor1 MD

My husband and I are planning a second baby. As I was obese and my first pregnancy involved gestational diabetes and hyper tension issues leading to a C section delivery I was keen to get my health in order in advance of the second baby.In October 2011, my weight was 84 kilos. I applied rules of healthy eating and daily walking and successfully brought the weight to 70 kilos by July 2013. At a height of 151 cm this meant a BMI of 31. One of my friends suggested a dietitian as I was already being good about my eating habits (eating moderately, on time, less sugar, less oil, no junk food, etc) with regular walks (about 4-5 days a week) without any weight loss. She suggested blood tests where my TSH problem was first diagnosed (TSH was 4.98 at the time). she prescribed 25mcg Thyronorm and I have been taking it from 1st August last year. She advised next blood test in 5-6 months along with a low calorie diet and moderate exercise plan. I have been good about diet and exercise for the last 5+ months and my weight was 61 kgs around February 9. The journey from 65 to 62 was particularly tough and long and took lot of effort and perseverance. Unfortunately despite being very good about both diet and exercise my weight increased to 63 kgs on February 13 - almost 5 pounds within just 4-5 days.My dietician again suggested a blood test. So last Saturday (about 5+ months after my first TSH, T3, T4 test) I got another blood test done. The latter two are fine. TSH is at 4.55.She advised that I visit an endocrinologist who has increased my dosage to 50 mcg Thyronorm every day for the next 6 weeks. He has also advised that until we bring my TSH levels to 2.5 I should not plan a baby. The doctor was vague about how long this process will take.Aside from weight gain and super difficulty in weight loss, I also have problems sleeping at night, fatigue, constipation and blurry vision concerns for the last few months. I am 34 years old.My question is how will we arrive at the best dosage that will help elevate the symptoms, bring TSH to safe levels, a healthy BMI, so that it's safe for me to conceive? And how much time will this take. At my age and with my history should I go in for a second pregnancy at all.

doctor1 MD

Im 34 weeks and 5 days pregnant, have gestational diabetes controlled with insulin injections 4x daily. I have had +++ blood in my urine with no cause found for a good few weeks but today when visiting the toilet i have had visable blood on the toilet tissue and my urine appears red tinged. Should i be concerned?