Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties

140 Doctors Online
Doctor Image
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

I will be looking into your question and guiding you through the process. Please write your question below.

Having knee pain. MRI showed meniscus between knee cartilage. Should I go for surgery?

Answered by
Dr. Michelle Gibson James

General & Family Physician

Practicing since :2001

Answered : 15926 Questions

Posted on Wed, 6 Feb 2013 in Bones, Muscles and Joints
Question: Around 3 months back, for an urgent office work , i was sitting all day in-front of my computer and since then i started having pain in left knee. Now, When i straighten my knee , it makes some sound as if two bones strike and sometimes it becomes very stiff and heavy. Last weekend , on a doctor's advice, i went for a knee MRI and here are the observations i got,
1) Horizontal tear within posterior horn and body of medial meniscus. Tear is
seen extending into outer surface.
2) Horizontal tear within posterior horn and body of lateral meniscus. Tear is
seen extending into outer surface.
3) Minimal joint effusion with small Baker's cyst.

Doctor explained me saying meniscus between knee cartilage has got torn-ed out and it needs a surgery to either repair the loose meniscus or remove it. Also he mentioned, i can wait for few months to see whether pain increases or decreases but he has asked me not to do any thing which puts pressure on knee

My questions are:-
1) How serious is this injury ? I mean how many people get affected by this and what impacts it has? Should i be worried about it more?
2) What are the options available apart from surgery?
3) What are the side affects of surgery? Will my normal life be back or it will be back with precautions?
4) I have heard about some magnetic resonance therapy for revival of bones and cartilage? Can they help me?
5) Any other thing that i am missing?
Answered by Dr. Michelle Gibson James 3 hours later
Hi, thanks for using healthcare magic

The menisci influence the transmission of force in the knee, the amount of contact force and the distribution of the load placed on the knee.
Most of the blood supply to the menisci is on the outside,this is important in terms of healing because blood is needed for any area of the body to heal well. For this reason, injuries to the outside or near the outside of the menisci are more likely to heal well.
Your injuries involve both the body (the inside), extending to the outside of the menisci.

(1) menisical injuries are more common in men, they are often sports related. They are associated with pain and deviation of the person's gait (way in which a person walks).As a result of the discomfort, it can mean that time is needed away from work and activity.
Delaying surgery can, in some persons, result in worsening of the tear and discomfort associated with it.

Treatment is affected by the extent and duration of the injury.It involves rehabilitation with a physiotherapist and surgery. The surgery is done through a small hole placed around the knee,it is not usually a large open wound.
Once the surgeons have made the small incision they insert a camera, during the procedure they can see the tears better on the screen and decide whether to repair, remove or leave the meniscus alone.
If you op not to have surgery then your doctor may suggest removal of the fluid (the effusion that was mentioned in the MRI) which may improve the symptoms temporarily, along with pain medication and rehab.

After surgery (repair or removal)- there may be initial pain and swelling which is treated with medication, ice packs.
After a few days exercises are introduced.There are a number of different exercises that the physiotherapist will ask you to do. Full weight bearing is held off a little longer if repair is done.

At present magnetic resonance therapy is experimental and there are not alot of studies as yet proving its effectivenes.

Hope this helps, feel free to ask any other questions
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar

The User accepted the expert's answer

Share on
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions
Medical Procedures
Lab Tests ,  
Medical Topics ,   ,  

Recent questions on  Meniscus

doctor1 MD

Hi I am 26 Male diagnosed for ACL ligament injury in Left Knee. This was happened on April 2009 as a result I consulted an orthopedic surgeon he advised me to take rest with a solid plaster all over my leg. After the period of 45 days I was able to manage to walk and later on things were adjustable with me. Dec 2011 I got a knee slip and MRI scan was taken the report is furnished below: IMPRESSION: ACL IS THIN; ORIENTATIONIS NOT PARALLEL TO INTERCONDYLAR ROOF SUGGESTIVE OF INCOMPETENT ACL. TO BE CORRELATED CLINICALLY. DEGENERATION OF POSTERIOR HORN OF MEDIAL MENISCUS NO TEAR. But I even though the Doctor advised me to take up surgery I did not and done ayurveda treatment was quiet manageable these days but, today Sep 2012 I got the same knee slip and pain in the knees I am able to walk with knee support. I am seriously worried and confused please help me out with a solution.

doctor1 MD

Hi Dr. moser, Wondering if you have any insight into this.... I had my first surgery today, knee arthroscopic for a torn meniscus. I seem to be having a pounding heartbeat while resting tonight. Is it frothe anesthesia or pain meds? Thanks for your time. Carrie

doctor1 MD

I had compound fracture with im rod & screws 7 years ago. The rod was removed 4 years ago & i had knee surgery for torn meniscus. I had occasional knee pain throughout the years that has since increased to a dull deep ache every other day. I lost my arch immediately after the first surgery its uncomfortable to walk long distance. While walking the knee often it clicks. Its caused chain reaction of other problems including back/hip pain & shoulder surgeries prbly due to crutches. Is it time to get the knee checked out to see whats going on?

doctor1 MD

I had meniscus repair surgery in my right knee 10 days ago, and have noticed a red rash on the leg that I had surgery on. Very itchy, and runs from the middle of my shin up to mid thigh. Is this something I should be worried about or is this a normal reaction?

doctor1 MD

I just had knee surgery to repair my meniscus (nov. 21st) . On Monday my calf swelled up, about 90% of that swelling has gone down but now my ankle is very swollen. I an not feeling any pain from the swelling but just below the area of my ankle...

doctor1 MD

Does methylpred mask a knee injury or can it actually fix the problem. I had a knee injury where I heard a pop sound followed by intense continuous pain and couldn't even walk on that leg and I started last night with 6 of these pills and. Now I...

doctor1 MD

this morning I woke up and sat at my computer for a couple of hours. When I got up to walk, I couldn't walk because the pain in my left knee almost knocked me on the floor with pain. I am using a cane right now but the pain in pretty intense when...