Get your Health question answered in 3 easy steps
A Doctor will be with you shortly
Ask a Doctor Now
179 Doctors are Online

General advice on protien supplements - Online Doctor Chats

Date : 21-Feb-2012
User rating for this question
Excellent Posted in: Exercise
Answered by

General & Family Physician
Practicing since : 2005
Answered : 2568 Questions
Doctor :   Hi
Doctor :   this is Dr Axxx
User :   Hi
Doctor :   How may I help you today?
User :   I go GYM daily...My GYM instructor is asking me to take protein powder as supplements
Doctor :   OK
User :   is it really good or will there be any side effects
Doctor :   It depends on the product
User :   he is suggesting WHEY Protein Optimum GOLD Standard
Doctor :   Most products which come now, are made of whey protein and is considered good
Doctor :   i understand,
Doctor :   products without steroids, are good, and i consider that as a good supplement
User :   Are protein powders good is my first question?
User :   ok
Doctor :   But instead of that, what you can do is have Egg whites
Doctor :   consider 5-10 egg whites daily, would be good, with reduction in carbohydrates, like rice.
User :   My instructor says protein intake should be 1.5 times body weight
Doctor :   EGG without the yellow yolk .
User :   ok
Doctor :   i understand, whats your weight?
User :   82Kgs
Doctor :   So your protein requiremnt is 140 GMS
Doctor :   SORRY 120 GMS daily
User :   yes..approx
Doctor :   for normal individuals it is 1 gm per Kg BODY WEIGHT
User :   I tried 6-8 egg whites...but it is creating lot of heat in the blisters on face
User :   ok
Doctor :   so FOR People wanting to build muscle , its a bit more than that.
User :   I am acutally looking at weight loss rather than build muscle
Doctor :   1 egg - has about 6gm s of protien
User :   ok...5 -10 around 60 gms
Doctor :   yes
User :   so protein powder is not required for me in this case
Doctor :   So consider eating about 15 EGG whites per day, would be the same as having whey powder
User :   ok
Doctor :   But Considering the cost factor
User :   is it fine to have so many Egg whites in 1 day
Doctor :   YES no problem
Doctor :   it does not matter, as its just protein.
User :   ok
User :   thank you for answering my queries
Doctor :   But Im not sure how much whey protein costs and its protein content
Doctor :   You are welcome,
Doctor :   But check out the protein content of whey, and cost also,
User :   2 lbs -- Rs 2000/-, 5lbs -- Rs 4100/-, 10lbs -- Rs. 7599/-
Doctor :   ok
User :   this is cost of Whey protein
Doctor :   30 INR x 30 days = 900 INR (consider 1 dozen eggs = 30 INR)
User :   yes...its much cheaper
Doctor :   But it depends how many days, will 2 Lbs of whey come for ?
User :   should be around 1 month
Doctor :   probably it maycome for 15 days or so, so i guess Egg whites + Pulses (bengal gram) - would make a good protein substitute.
User :   ok
Doctor :   You can consult a dietician, who can help yoiu with making a diet, with 120 gm protein daily
Doctor :   So that will work out for good
User :   ok
Doctor :   Also since you are looking for overall fitness, and burning calories, i dont think Protien intake matters
User :   my instructor is very keen on protein intake
Doctor :   it matters only if you want to increase weight, and body building
User :   ok
Doctor :   Just pacify him that you are taking it at home
User :   ok
Doctor :   he does not need to know, whether you are taking or not.
Doctor :   Probably he wants to sell you the same, and he wants to make some profit
User :   may be
Doctor :   but as far as i know, you can have the same protin intake from natural indian diet, than going for costly alternatives like whey, which is probably overated.
User :   ok
Doctor :   take egg whites, eat fish (if You are a non vegetarian),
Doctor :   these things, contain more protein, than rest
User :   yes will do the same
Doctor :   Also mutton contains more protein ,but it need to be prepared in such a way that you dont put more oil in it.
Doctor :   soya bean, bengal gram, chana, contains more protein if you are a vegetarain
User :   ok
Doctor :   these are very cheap and good alternatives
User :   ok
Doctor :   consult a dietician , in our panel, and you will get a good diet advice as per your needs.
User :   sure will do that
User :   thanks for your advice
Doctor :   You are absolutely welcome.
Doctor :   Is there anything else i can help you with.
Doctor :   thank you for consulting me here.
User :   nothing else
Doctor :   bye for now.
User :   thank you..bye
Question is related to
Diseases and Conditions
© Ebix, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
All the information, content and live chat provided on the site is intended to be for informational purposes only, and not a substitute for professional or medical advice. You should always speak with your doctor before you follow anything that you read on this website. Any health question asked on this site will be visible to the people who browse this site. Hence, the user assumes the responsibility not to divulge any personally identifiable information in the question. Use of this site is subject to our Terms & Conditions
Already Rated.
Your rating:

Ask a Doctor