Sign-in to Ask A Doctor - 24x7
OR
Sign in with GoogleGet your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties
Is It Legal To Place A Magnet Over A Defibrillator To Cause It To Malfunction In Order To Cause Death?
Is it legal to place a magnet over a defibrillator to cause it to malfunction in order to cause death??
This was done to my father and i am trying to find out if in fact it was legal. It was not that i know of, ordered by a physician. It did in fact cause my fathers death. This was done by my sister, she is an RN. She, along with another nurse working at the time are the ones that placed it over the defibrillator. It was not done to save him, and was done without the orders of a physician. I just want to know if I have any legal recourse as my father had a strong will to live and would have never agreed to this.
This was done to my father and i am trying to find out if in fact it was legal. It was not that i know of, ordered by a physician. It did in fact cause my fathers death. This was done by my sister, she is an RN. She, along with another nurse working at the time are the ones that placed it over the defibrillator. It was not done to save him, and was done without the orders of a physician. I just want to know if I have any legal recourse as my father had a strong will to live and would have never agreed to this.
Sat, 24 Mar 2012
hello n welcome ....
first of all use of magnet is commonly done by physician and during PROGRAMMING of pacemaker defibrillator. usually use of magnet done by physician in many occasions therapeutically.
if it happens by mistake or unknowingly even then death is unlikely. becoz magnet usually fix that pacemaker defibrillator in a fixed rate or programme.
i think whatever they have done may be therapeutically needed in that particular case.
that is the reason its usually says that person with defibrillator/pacemaker should avoid MRI /SCANNER in airport. that can cause malfunction but death is unlikely.
good luck ....
first of all use of magnet is commonly done by physician and during PROGRAMMING of pacemaker defibrillator. usually use of magnet done by physician in many occasions therapeutically.
if it happens by mistake or unknowingly even then death is unlikely. becoz magnet usually fix that pacemaker defibrillator in a fixed rate or programme.
i think whatever they have done may be therapeutically needed in that particular case.
that is the reason its usually says that person with defibrillator/pacemaker should avoid MRI /SCANNER in airport. that can cause malfunction but death is unlikely.
good luck ....
I find this answer helpful
User's Response
Linda Smith's
Response
Uh, no... not only is it illegal but the Doctor should have known better. Rather accidental or purposely it is "Malpractice," in the medical field there is no room for mistakes because mistakes obviously cost lives. Was this Dr. Kevorkian???
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer.
For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service
[Sample answer]
Related questions you may be interested in
Recent questions on MRI
Loading Online Doctors....